It's got the look, right? Battered half-sheet pan with wax paper, haphazardly shaped rough oblong pie... this could be New Haven! Alas, it was not to be. Piece's pies are eminently ordinary. Not bad, mind you. If we were local college students, and this was down the street, and we had pitchers of the good beer on the table, (and we'd never been to New Haven), we'd probably be happy. But the pies were an over-topped, sodden mess, and the flavors just weren't there.
We won't even count the awful guacamole against Piece. We should have known better than to order it.