The most memorable local eateries along the highways and back roads of America
Sign In | Register for Free!
Restaurants Recipes Forums EatingTours Merchandise FAQ Maps Insider
Forum Themes:
Welcome !

 Baseball Roadtrip 2007: Pennsylvania/Western NYS

Author Message

  • Total Posts: 1384
  • Joined: 5/11/2005
  • Location: Bergen County, NJ
  • Roadfood Insider
Baseball Roadtrip 2007: Pennsylvania/Western NYS Thu, 08/2/07 6:09 PM (permalink)
Baseball Roadtrip 2007 is complete!

Due to life interfering with play, this year’s trip was the shortest one in our 14 year history. We still had tons of fun, drove too many miles, watched some great baseball, saw a new slice of America, and ate a lot of great food.

DAY ONE- New York City to Syracuse 334 miles
We didn’t leave NYC until 2:00pm on Saturday. We only had 5 hours until game time in Syracuse, but thanks to, we had two off-the-beaten-path spots directly in our path. The first:

GIANETTO’S- Moosic, PA. Moosic was a few miles off our path, but the pictures on Roadfood looked so good, we had to stop for a slice. Our first problem was the fact that there are TWO Main Streets in Moosic! The one that Google points to (as well as the GPS in the car) was a dirt road in the middle of a trailer park. That ain’t the right one. We doubled back and found the correct Main Street, we found Gianetto’s. The second problem was this:

Turns out, they only make pizza on weekdays, but the gal behind the counter was just pulling a fresh pie out of the oven, just to have some on hand. Lucky for us!

I totally agree with Michael Stern’s review: this pizza is about as un-Italian as pizza can possibly be (which is fine!). The sauce and cheese are fine, but the crust is totally different than any Pizza I’ve had before. It was more like fresh baked and toasted white bread. It was so airy, it kind of disappears in your mouth as you eat it. Very good stuff, but not really worth a special trip out of your way. The pizza definitely tastes like something someone would make in their home kitchen. The atmosphere is odd. Kind of half-convenience store, half-abandoned convenience store:

I wish I had the opportunity to sample the crazy combinations that they serve during the week, but such is life. Back on the road…Cortland, NY was due north of us:

DOUG’S FISH FRY- Cortland, NY. We only had time for a quick take-out order so we went for the “fish dinner” which is a fish sandwich, fries and cole slaw. Here’s a photo of that meal plated on the dashboard going 50 miles per hour (the way good food is meant to be served):

Everything at Doug’s is cooked in peanut oil and I think that makes all the difference. This might have been the best fish sandwich I’ve ever had. Crisp, flavorful and fresh. They had malt vinegar at the condiment bar, which is the perfect accompaniment to fried fish. The cole slaw and fries are also outstanding. They were also serving frozen custard with fresh pick blueberries, but sadly, we had to pass on that. We still had Dinosaur BBQ on the horizon and needed to save room.

Next stop was Alliance Stadium in Syracuse to see the Sky Chiefs vs. the Buffalo Bisons. The stadium is bland, concrete and totally forgettable, plopped down on the outskirts of town by the interstate. Only two things stood out: one was the dreadful artificial turf:

The other thing that stood out was a local gem at the concession stand- Salt Potatoes. I generally never eat at a ballpark, but we had to try these. Basically, they tasted like boiled potatoes with some salt:

The moment the last out was recorded, we ignored the fireworks show and made a bee-line to our next stop, and what a stop it was:

DINOSAUR BBQ: Syracuse, NY. I’ve been kind of avoiding the Harlem location until I could make it up to the original. We arrived at about 10:00, and surprisingly, there was no wait. I’m sure the wait at the same restaurant in NYC on a Saturday night is over an hour. Since it was late, we limited our feast to three items: a half-slab of ribs, a plate of wings (two sauces) and some fried green tomatoes. First the ribs:

I’ve been all over, and I’ve eaten a LOT of ribs. These were my favorite of all time. For me, ribs should “come” off the bone, not fall off. They should be tender, but still have some tooth. These were cooked to absolute perfection. They’re moist, but not dripping in sauce. They had spice to them, but they weren’t dusty. They had a slightly caramelized crust without having a burnt taste. PERFECT. The wings were great too, but next to those ribs, they were an afterthought. We had two kinds: honey mustard and garlic chipotle. These are not fried, but smoked then grilled. Really quite good.

The fried green tomatoes and all the other sides were passable, but nothing to rave about.

Next stop was our motel in Farmington, NY (about 70 miles west) for some much needed sleep.

DAY TWO- Farmington, NY to Erie, PA 175 miles
After rising early and eating some crappy oatmeal and bad fruit for breakfast at a diner in Farmington, we lit off to Erie to catch a 1:00 game. Jerry Uht Field is a nice little AA stadium in Downtown Erie. Nothing there is overblown (unlike 99% of all new stadiums). It’s a pleasant place with great sightlines.

It was Negro League Appreciation Day and the Sea Wolves were wearing the jerseys of the Erie Pontiacs. Nice day at the ballpark.

I was still stuffed from all the roadfooding we did the day before, so I skipped lunch altogether and headed straight for the beaches of Presque Isle State Park (really a peninsula into Lake Erie). I didn’t quite know what to expect, but I was really pleasantly surprised to find one of the nicest non-ocean beaches I’ve ever seen:

We finally checked into our hotel, had a quick dip in the overly-heated pool and started asking around about local restaurants. Erie is the kind of town that’s sadly becoming the norm in this country: a depressed old downtown, with every big-box store and chain restaurant imaginable thriving out by the interstate. You can really see how great downtown Erie must have been in its heyday. Now, like a thousand other cities, most of the old stores and restaurants are gone, driven out of business by local economics, competition by mega-stores, and the constant lowering of standards. It’s very sad.

We were able to find a local, family run Italian restaurant called Serafini’s in downtown Erie (left the camera in the hotel). It turns out it’s been in operation since 1938. Very typical red-sauce Italian. We split a platter of chicken cacciatore (excellent) and a combo platter of meatballs, sausage and manicotti over spaghetti drenched in marinara (not so great). After that, we caught a movie (The Simpsons) and got some sleep.

DAY THREE-Erie to New York City 515 miles (!)

With a LONG day ahead of us, we grabbed some coffee and donuts for the road at Tim Horton’s (after failing to find a local coffee shop in the area of our hotel). What’s with all the hype about this place? Absolutely nothing special. Very commercial tasting coffee and donuts.

Our first destination was Penn State for ice cream, but our crappy corporate breakfast left us hungry for something substantial for lunch. Somewhere on Route 322 between I80 and State College we saw this sign:

How could we pass on “Award Winning BBQ” in a gas station???

GIOVANNI’S FOOD EXPRESS- Route 322, Somewhere in Pennsylvania (sorry I didn’t grab a menu with location info). Giovanni’s is a lot of things: a gas station, a convenience store, and a genuine roadside BBQ joint. As you can see by the hand-written menu, they try to do an awful lot:

I got the BBQ chicken. It was very good, nice and moist, but a little saucy.

They served all the typical side dishes, but one stood out: Haluska. The gal behind the counter informed me that it was a German delicacy and described it as “cabbage, noodles, sausage with just enough butter to cook it”:

It was delicious, but had WAY more butter than was needed to cook it! Nice balance between the noodles and the cabbage.

With a belly full of BBQ and haluska, we continued our drive towards State College.

THE BERKEY CREAMERY at Penn State University. Located in the Food Sciences building on the Penn State campus, this place is like a dream. The freshest, most flavorful ice cream I’ve ever had:

On the left is Vanilla with Peanut Butter Swirl, made with real vanilla beans. On the right is Death By Chocolate: chocolate ice cram with pieces of fudge and a chocolate swirl. It’s even better than it looks.

I had no choice but to buy a few pints and pay the extra $10 to have it packed on dry ice for my wife.

At this point, we decided to forget the trip to Philly and Campbell Field in Camden, NJ. It was just too much driving for one day. I had always been curious to see Centralia, PA. It’s a kind of a ghost town in Pennsylvania that was destroyed by an underground coal mine fire back in the 1960’s, and the fire still burns to this day. I had done some research on the town before the trip, so we decided to go see for ourselves. One thing’s for certain, it’s no tourist attraction. If you don’t know about it, you’ll never know Centralia ever existed. Route 61 north of Ashland makes an abrupt turn around what used to be a thriving town. The old road is just cut off:

There’s only one marker to let you know something happened there:

It’s very sad and creepy as to walk around and see all these driveways that used to lead to homes, and now just lead to smoldering rubble:

The mine has been burning for 44 years, with no signs of it ever being extinguished. The government bought out most of the homeowners and relocated them back in the 80's, but one or two have stayed. I only saw 2 homes that looked like they were inhabited. One of them is bolstered on both sides with giant I-beams to prevent them from collapsing. I think it once stood in the middle of a series of row houses. The beams are covered with a brick-looking veneer, I suppose to make it appear cozy?

The story of Centralia is a very sad one, but it’s part of American history, and really pretty fascinating.

By this point we were exhausted, and started heading for home. We made great time though the rest of PA and into the great state of New Jersey, so we decided to drive into the Ironbound section of Newark for a Portuguese dinner. We picked the first place that looked busy and sat down for an awesome feast of fish, potatoes, bricked chicken, black-eyed peas and broccoli rabe. I have no idea the name of the place or the exact location (sorry!), but if you’re in the Ironbound area, just head for the gigantic Pathmark, and check out the restaurants on the main drag around the edge of the shopping center (right by the post office- Ironbound station). Great ethnic food to be had there.

Next stop, my own bed. Nice short trip (if you can count 1,100 miles in 3 days as “short”). We caught only 2 games in 3 days, but we saw some great country and ate a lot of great food.


    • Total Posts: 7407
    • Joined: 1/18/2001
    • Location: East Greenwich/ Warwick, RI
    • Roadfood Insider
    RE: Baseball Roadtrip 2007: Pennsylvania/Western NYS Thu, 08/2/07 6:35 PM (permalink)

    I'm dissapointed- no photos of YOU I want to see if you've aged or not!

    Halushki is actually Polish. When I lived in pittsburgh, many of my co- workers of Polish and Slovak ancestry would bring it in for lunch.

      • Total Posts: 1560
      • Joined: 2/4/2004
      • Location: scotch plains, NJ
      RE: Baseball Roadtrip 2007: Pennsylvania/Western NYS Thu, 08/2/07 6:51 PM (permalink)
      Great trip report, I love to read the reports even if I'm not planning to head in that particular area in the near futre.

      Re; Moosic: Funny, but the EXACT same thing happened to me last year when I plotted out a day trip to the Old Forge area for pizza. Mapquest led me to the wrong Main Street in Moosic. I just gave up trying to find the real Main Street and headed off to the 9 other Pizza places I had mapped out in advance.


        • Total Posts: 6317
        • Joined: 7/6/2006
        • Location: Live at Saint Clair
        • Roadfood Insider
        RE: Baseball Roadtrip 2007: Pennsylvania/Western NYS Thu, 08/2/07 9:02 PM (permalink)

        I loved your report. Sometimes it is not what we expected to do that makes the trip the most fun.

        I am glad you shared your adventure, i too love going to minor league games. there is such a different atmosphere at a minor league park.

        The creamery @ Penn State is legendary and DEEEEEEELISHHHUSSSSS! i wanted to lick the puter screen.


          • Total Posts: 1743
          • Joined: 10/23/2000
          • Location: Baltimore, MD
          RE: Baseball Roadtrip 2007: Pennsylvania/Western NYS Thu, 08/2/07 9:43 PM (permalink)
          Was Peachy Paterno on the menu at the Creamery?

            • Total Posts: 1384
            • Joined: 5/11/2005
            • Location: Bergen County, NJ
            • Roadfood Insider
            RE: Baseball Roadtrip 2007: Pennsylvania/Western NYS Thu, 08/2/07 11:17 PM (permalink)
            Originally posted by signman

            Was Peachy Paterno on the menu at the Creamery?

            Yes it was. I think Peachy Paterno is always one of the 15 or flavors available.

              • Total Posts: 1384
              • Joined: 5/11/2005
              • Location: Bergen County, NJ
              • Roadfood Insider
              RE: Baseball Roadtrip 2007: Pennsylvania/Western NYS Fri, 08/3/07 10:35 AM (permalink)
              Originally posted by wanderingjew


              I'm dissapointed- no photos of YOU I want to see if you've aged or not!

              Well, considering that we haven't seen each other in about 15 years, I would have to say, no, of course I haven't aged a bit!

              Halushki is actually Polish. When I lived in pittsburgh, many of my co- workers of Polish and Slovak ancestry would bring it in for lunch.

              I'm sure all of eastern Europe has versions of this dish. The gal at the counter told me it was German, and it was spelled "Haluska" on the menu. I am half Polish, and I never saw anything like this in my family. I saw plently of noodles and cabbacge with butter, but never with sausage (the fact that my Polish grandmother was Kosher probably had something to do with it). Anything with egg noodles was called "lukshun" in my family (lukshun soup, lukshun and cheese, lukshun and cabbage, etc...).

                RE: Baseball Roadtrip 2007: Pennsylvania/Western NYS Fri, 08/3/07 10:37 AM (permalink)
                Excellent report with great pics!

                We actually crossed paths this past weekend. I also ate at Genotti's in Moosic on Saturday, but I was sitting there eating pizza at 8:00AM. The only thing they had was the red pizza and you described it perfectly....much better than I ever could. I also enjoyed it, but I wouldn't make a special trip back for it.

                On Friday night, I stopped at the Penn State Creamery, which was the first time since they renovated. It is so much bigger and nicer now. Had one scoop of Peachy Paterno and one of Bittersweet Mint. The portions are huge and the ice cream itself is wonderful. I liked it even more than I remembered.

                I did see the bbq sign at the convenience store that made you stop in, but I passed it by to head to Clem's. I'm glad you liked what you had.

                Thanks again for the great report!

                  • Total Posts: 949
                  • Joined: 6/25/2003
                  • Location: Las Cruces, NM
                  RE: Baseball Roadtrip 2007: Pennsylvania/Western NYS Fri, 08/3/07 11:21 AM (permalink)
                  I have a keen interest in Centralia, and have gone there a few times. Last time I took my video camera with me, and went into one of those abandoned lots. Many have been turned into makeshift dumps. I remember taking a piece of plastic from a discarded toy, throwing into a fissured piece of ground, and watching it melt almost instantaneously. The first time I was ever there, I was working for a mapping company, and had the Columbia County road maps in the back of the car on a laptop PC. I saw the grid pattern of the streets, and anticipated a fairly thriving small village. Looking at the screen of that PC in the back was a major requirement of the job, so I did not notice when the driver pulled into the outskirts of the town, and I looked up to find..... nothing at all. I was astonished at what I was looking at. Streets with nothing on them except weeds, with nature reclaiming the landscape. I've been keenly interested in this place ever since.

                    • Total Posts: 3531
                    • Joined: 5/1/2004
                    • Location: Egg Harbor Township, NJ
                    RE: Baseball Roadtrip 2007: Pennsylvania/Western NYS Sat, 08/4/07 9:36 PM (permalink)
                    great trip report and pics, pigiron...

                    that ice cream looks as good as the yummy choc. chip I had at Jaxon's in south Florida. I know how you feel about thinking it was the best ever, as I felt that way, too..

                    and those chicken wings look good, too. I may get the same 2 flavors you got at the dinosaur bbq , when I'm in Syracuse (for the NY state fair Labor Day weekend.)
                    Plus some brisket at the Dinosaur. (wish they had beef ribs)

                    you did so much in 3 days and 1100 miles , pigiron!

                      • Total Posts: 5546
                      • Joined: 8/4/2005
                      • Location: Crofton, MD
                      RE: Baseball Roadtrip 2007: Pennsylvania/Western NYS Mon, 08/6/07 6:20 PM (permalink)
                      great trip report. I've also had Gianetto's Pizza (which I personally cannot stand. I thinks it's aweful. But, that's just me.) Doug's Fish Fry (the best IMO as well - I used to be a regular at the one in Skaneateles when I was a teacher in that area), Salt Potatoes (but never at the stadium. next time you want salt potatoes, I'll give you some places to try them), Dinosaur BBQ (I always get the ribs. I've never had their wings, but have made wings using their sauces. It's not a Buffalo Wing, but the sauces make a nice wing anyways and are always a hit when I make them for parties). And I've had many scoops of ice cream at The Creamery at Penn State. It's my favorite ice cream any where.
                      I like your pit stop at that BBQ joint. I think I've gotten gas at that BP on the way to Penn State, it looks familiar, but never had the food. I always waited out for a Penn State Sub Shop.

                      great pics. Look's like fun.

                        • Total Posts: 103
                        • Joined: 8/2/2007
                        • Location: State College, PA
                        RE: Baseball Roadtrip 2007: Pennsylvania/Western NYS Mon, 08/6/07 6:44 PM (permalink)
                        You can tell you're in the coal region when there are bullet holes in all the signs.

                        Grew up right down the hill from Centralia. Looking pretty bad there. Next time you're in State College try Prospector's Allegheny Rib Co. (aka Jethro's). I think they're great but I really haven't been around to a lot of rib places.

                        Enjoyed this trip report. Thanks!

                          • Total Posts: 1066
                          • Joined: 1/18/2006
                          • Location: Schertz, TX
                          RE: Baseball Roadtrip 2007: Pennsylvania/Western NYS Tue, 08/7/07 9:33 AM (permalink)
                          What a great report.I love hearing about other peoples trips.
                          I have heard of Centralia,PA.I think it was even on the tv show 60 Minutes years ago.

                          I know of some ghost towns around here in the San Antonio area,where you can see some buildings and that.Still a little life in them.Then there are places like Alum Creek and Mound Creek which are just cemeteries left.

                          Your fish sandwich looked good.Haven't had one in ages.
                          If you ever get to Texas check out the San Antonio Missions at Wolf Stadium.Their mascot is the Puffy Taco,i kid you not.It was voted most unusual mascot by Sports Illustrated.
                          Henry's Puffy Tacos if I recall correctly,is one of their sponsors.

                            • Total Posts: 1384
                            • Joined: 5/11/2005
                            • Location: Bergen County, NJ
                            • Roadfood Insider
                            RE: Baseball Roadtrip 2007: Pennsylvania/Western NYS Tue, 08/7/07 12:43 PM (permalink)
                            Originally posted by HollyDolly

                            If you ever get to Texas check out the San Antonio Missions at Wolf Stadium.Their mascot is the Puffy Taco,i kid you not.It was voted most unusual mascot by Sports Illustrated.
                            Henry's Puffy Tacos if I recall correctly,is one of their sponsors.

                            Been there, done that! Roadtrip 2001 included "Enron" Field, San Antonio and Round Rock (Austin). MAN, there was some good food on THAT trip. I don't believe that I've had a chicken fried steak since my trip to Texas in 2001.

                              • Total Posts: 59
                              • Joined: 8/14/2007
                              • Location: Macungie, PA
                              RE: Baseball Roadtrip 2007: Pennsylvania/Western NYS Sat, 08/18/07 10:41 AM (permalink)
                              Great trip report. I love the pictures. I go by Moosic on occasion, hopefully I can try Gianatto's for pizza.
                                Online Bookmarks Sharing: Share/Bookmark

                                Jump to:

                                Current active users

                                There are 0 members and 1 guests.

                                Icon Legend and Permission

                                • New Messages
                                • No New Messages
                                • Hot Topic w/ New Messages
                                • Hot Topic w/o New Messages
                                • Locked w/ New Messages
                                • Locked w/o New Messages
                                • Read Message
                                • Post New Thread
                                • Reply to message
                                • Post New Poll
                                • Submit Vote
                                • Post reward post
                                • Delete my own posts
                                • Delete my own threads
                                • Rate post

                                2000-2014 ASPPlayground.NET Forum Version 3.9
                                What is Roadfood?  |   Privacy Policy  |   Contact   Copyright 2011 -