I took on an experiment to compare traditional kneaded bread with the no-knead bread technique that was first made popular by Jim Lahey and written up by Mark Bittman in the NY Times in November 2006. This is their video.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=13Ah9ES2yTU My recipe for both was.
2 cups unbleached bread flour
1 cup whole wheat flour
1-1/4 teaspoon sea salt
3 table spoons pure University of Minnesota Arboretum maple syrup
wheat bran as needed for flour handling
Instant dry yeast
water
The variables were the yeast, water, and baking techniques and temperatures.
For the no-knead bread I added 1-5/8 cups water.
For the kneaded bread I added 1-1/4 cups water.
For the no-knead bread I added 1/4 teaspoon of yeast.
For the kneaded bread I added 1 teaspoon of yeast.
For the kneaded bread I mixed the ingredients together and brought the mix to a ball that I then proceeded to knead for about 10 minutes. When you knead by hand you can actually feel the gluten developing.
For the no-knead bread I mixed the ingredients together just long enough for the mix to come together. The no-knead is an almost unhandleable soupy mix. Here is the comparison of the no-knead in the red bowl and the kneaded dough ball in the white bowl.
I covered the no-knead bowl with clear wrap and set it aside overnight for 19 hours total. I let the kneaded ball rise to double for about 2 hours and punched it down once. Then I turned on the oven at a temperature of 375 degrees to pre-heat the stone. After about another hour the kneaded dough had risen again and I formed it into a boule ball and slipped it onto the stone with a peel.
This is the resulting bread after 50 minutes.
The next morning I dumped the no-knead mix on the counter and folded it twice just like the video.
I put it on a towel with wheat bran to prevent it from sticking and then covered it and let it rise again for another hour.
After an hour I put a enameled Dutch oven in the oven to pre-heat at 475 degrees. After about 20 minutes I dumped the no-knead mix into the Dutch oven like so and covered it with the Dutch oven lid.
After 30 minutes I took the lid off and let it bake for another 20 minutes. This is after 30 minutes.
This is the finished no-knead bread out of the oven.
The no-knead bread had the better crust and slightly better taste but a direct taste comparison was impossible with the breads coming out of the oven on separate days. I suspect the kneaded bread could have been better if I had refrigerator fermented it overnight the way I do my pizza dough and not rushed it. I expected the crumb to be different but both were tight. However, as I sliced deeper into the no-knead bread the crumb did get a lot looser. The variable from the standard no-knead recipes was the use of the University of Minnesota Landscape Arboretum pure maple syrup. It was just something I wanted to try. I don't know if the syrup affected the experiment.
What I don't understand is the claim that no-knead is simpler. It takes longer in over all time, it gets rather messy with dirtying a towel, the counter for both has to be cleaned up, the Dutch oven has to be cooled and cleaned, and there seems to be a lot more steps just to save 10 minutes of kneading it seems and kneading is one of the more enjoyable aspects of baking bread. I will probably continue to perfect my regular bread baking techniques. It was fun.