The most memorable local eateries along the highways and back roads of America
Sign In | Register for Free!
Restaurants Recipes Forums EatingTours Merchandise FAQ Maps Insider

 Correct Terms Fried,Grilled,BBQ

Author Message
stevencarry

  • Total Posts: 359
  • Joined: 2/18/2006
  • Location: San Rafael, CA
Correct Terms Fried,Grilled,BBQ Sun, 03/12/06 12:47 AM (permalink)
I say if you cook something on a flat surface like a griddle you are frying (not deep frying) frying
If you are cooking it on something that has spaces between heating elements,leaves grill marks,looks like an old gas heater or the front of an old Buick, You are Grilling
If you cook it in a closed space with only hot smoke from a not direct fire source you are BBQing.

I'm tired of ordering a "Grilled Something" only to notice they are frying it.
Or order BBQ and see they are grilling it and putting on sauce.

The worst is Korean BBQ which is fried, what's up with that ?

What's your opinion on this ?
 
#1
    BuddyRoadhouse

    • Total Posts: 3409
    • Joined: 12/10/2004
    • Location: Des Plaines, IL
    RE: Correct Terms Fried,Grilled,BBQ Sun, 03/12/06 2:00 AM (permalink)
    Depending on the dish, most Korean "BBQ" I've seen falls under the heading of grilling.

    I consider your first example to be "griddling", like when they slap a burger on the griddle at the local diner. Unless there is at least a half inch of oil or fat in an enclosed frying pan (pan fried chicken f'rinstance), it ain't frying

    Between you and me I'll agree with you 100% on your strict "grilling" and "barbecue" definitions. However, the language does evolve, and through common usage the word "barbecue" has come to refer to both "grilling" and "barbecue" as we understand them. At no time, however should the act of "griddling" be referred to as "barbecue".

    Just my two pennies.

    Buddy

    P.S. You can't fool me, you're really using this thread to start a fight in the "crock pot bbq" discussion, aren't you?

    b.
     
    #2
      BT

      • Total Posts: 3588
      • Joined: 7/3/2004
      • Location: San Francisco, CA
      RE: Correct Terms Fried,Grilled,BBQ Sun, 03/12/06 2:06 AM (permalink)
      I think in order to be "frying", there has to be some oil involved. An unoiled metal surface, whether pierced or not, would be a grill.

      Far be it from me to tell Koreans how to produce Korean BBQ (though I thought it was essentially grilled), but I'll agree with you on American BBQ even though I personally use the term more broadly to mean pretty much anything edible produced with charcoal in the back yard (as far as I'm concerned, those gas things don't count).

      Now what's your response to "Thai BBQ" such as what was produced by the restaurant of that name in SF? Personally, I couldn't distinguish it from satay, but again, I'm not Thai so I never tried to tell them how to make it (and I wish I could get some--with peanut sauce--regardless of how they made it).

      PS: Having read Buddy's post above, which appeared while I was writing mine, I'll point out I use a "Crock Pot BBQ" but I never called what it produces BBQ. I call the only thing I've made with it so far "pulled pork" which does not specify how the pork got cooked to the stage where it can be "pulled".
       
      #3
        stevencarry

        • Total Posts: 359
        • Joined: 2/18/2006
        • Location: San Rafael, CA
        RE: Correct Terms Fried,Grilled,BBQ Sun, 03/12/06 2:24 AM (permalink)
        Buddy, if you fried an egg you would not have a half an inch of oil. What are you thinking? You would just have a "coating" of fat. I thought to "saute" would be with some oil otherwise whenever you see cooking on flat cast iron www.lodgemfg.com like my reversible griddle/grill or
        probably most diners they are cooking on a surface that is never oiled,greased,or cleaned because that is how it works, the fat "seasons" the surface.
        Buddy, no I have not read the crock/bbq. One is steaming, one is smoking, so I don't know how those two would go together. And I have only seen a giant griddle in a Korean place. In fact the only thing I think they should be known for
        is "Kim Chee" everything else is run of the mill.
         
        #4
          Jimeats

          • Total Posts: 3175
          • Joined: 8/15/2005
          • Location: Ipswich Ma
          RE: Correct Terms Fried,Grilled,BBQ Sun, 03/12/06 7:08 AM (permalink)
          Shoot now I don't know how to cook my Grilled cheese sanwiches anymore, Thanks alot! Chow Jim
           
          #5
            dreamzpainter

            • Total Posts: 1609
            • Joined: 2/6/2005
            • Location: jacksonville, FL
            RE: Correct Terms Fried,Grilled,BBQ Sun, 03/12/06 10:02 AM (permalink)
            "steam" it in the crockpot jim
             
            #6
              stevencarry

              • Total Posts: 359
              • Joined: 2/18/2006
              • Location: San Rafael, CA
              RE: Correct Terms Fried,Grilled,BBQ Sun, 03/12/06 2:32 PM (permalink)
              quote:
              Originally posted by Jimeats

              Shoot now I don't know how to cook my Grilled cheese sanwiches anymore, Thanks alot! Chow Jim

              Maybe they should start a comedy only thread because I am serious about this topic and yet you got me good on my childhood favorite.
               
              #7
                mayor al

                • Total Posts: 14007
                • Joined: 8/20/2002
                • Location: Louisville area, Southern Indiana
                • Roadfood Insider
                RE: Correct Terms Fried,Grilled,BBQ Sun, 03/12/06 3:33 PM (permalink)
                Once again, Regionalism within the American use of English seems to make this an unanswerable question. Most of America has at least gained a basic acceptance of the difference between BBQ and Grill (both are VERBS) when it comes to 'cooking out'! That's as neutral a statement as I can make on the terminology! 'Low and Slow' vs 'Hot and Fast'!! Then we have to consider Frying... How much pan-lubricant does it take to make the 'Grill' a 'Fry' or a 'Saute'? (all three words are used in their role as a VERB !)
                When I worked the Burger Grill at HOJO's more than a generation ago, it was a solid flat metal surface, heated from beneath by gas flames. We didn't refer to the burgers as 'fried'. They and the hot dogs were 'grilled' on that slab of steel.
                Now I consider the metal mesh of steel rods on the outdoor cooking unit to be a grill. Cooking meat on it (or other stuff too) will produce various geometric burn marks on the product cooking to give it a unique appearance and the air circulation will help the food acquire some of the flavor of the wood, charcoal or even () gas that is providing the heat.
                TO FRY- The dictionary says "to cook over high heat in oil or fat." That implys a cooking vessel with some sort of sides to hold in the "oil or fat" while the cooking is going on. No reference is made to the volume of the "oil or fat" being used. I won't even begin to consider the variations between 'fried' and 'deep fried' !

                Last comment deals with the "Grilled Cheese" My mom used to call them Toasted Cheese Sandwiches, because the bread was dry, the cheese put on and the open face then toasted under a broiler (HOT BROWN style). When she buttered the bread, inserted the cheese and made a 'closed'(2 pieces of bread) sandwich, which was then heated (grilled)-both sides- on a hot flat surface or 'frying pan' she would call it a GRILLED CHEESE SANDWICH.
                Thank you for your kind attention.
                 
                #8
                  stevencarry

                  • Total Posts: 359
                  • Joined: 2/18/2006
                  • Location: San Rafael, CA
                  RE: Correct Terms Fried,Grilled,BBQ Sun, 03/12/06 3:45 PM (permalink)
                  Al, thanks for the input and I might mention deep frying is the only one I
                  thought was universal. Anything immersed i.e. fish and chips, tempura etc
                   
                  #9
                    1bbqboy

                    • Total Posts: 4022
                    • Joined: 11/20/2000
                    • Location: Rogue Valley
                    RE: Correct Terms Fried,Grilled,BBQ Sun, 03/12/06 4:05 PM (permalink)
                    quote:
                    Originally posted by stevencarry

                    Al, thanks for the input and I might mention deep frying is the only one I
                    thought was universal. Anything immersed i.e. fish and chips, tempura etc

                    Tacos!
                     
                    #10
                      porkbeaks

                      • Total Posts: 2111
                      • Joined: 5/6/2005
                      • Location: Hoschton/Braselton, GA
                      RE: Correct Terms Fried,Grilled,BBQ Sun, 03/12/06 4:15 PM (permalink)
                      quote:
                      Originally posted by stevencarry

                      .....If you are cooking it on something that has spaces between heating elements,leaves grill marks,looks like an old gas heater or the front of an old Buick, You are Grilling....
                      I'm tired of ordering a "Grilled Something" only to notice they are frying it.
                      What's your opinion on this ?


                      I feel your pain and I totally agree with the disappointment of expecting something barbecued only to be served that something grilled.

                      However, when I'm in a diner and the menu lists something grilled, such as onions, I know they're going to be "fried" on a griddle. On the same note, I've never seen a Weber in a Bar & Grill. pb
                       
                      #11
                        BuddyRoadhouse

                        • Total Posts: 3409
                        • Joined: 12/10/2004
                        • Location: Des Plaines, IL
                        RE: Correct Terms Fried,Grilled,BBQ Sun, 03/12/06 5:00 PM (permalink)
                        quote:
                        Originally posted by stevencarry

                        Good point. And another thing, Al's reference to the dictionary.
                        I have dictionarys from several decades (except this one) and they all say
                        different things. So I never quote them. But how about this from the 1982
                        Random house college edition. "gay" 1. having or showing a joyous mood 2.
                        bright or showy "gay colors" 3. given to or abounding in social or other pleasures. I will bet the new edition does not say that.
                        Why the heck wouldn't it?

                        There may be an additional, contemporary definition, but gay still means gay as defined above.

                        Buddy
                         
                        #12
                          MilwFoodlovers

                          • Total Posts: 2921
                          • Joined: 3/31/2001
                          • Location: Milwaukee, WI
                          RE: Correct Terms Fried,Grilled,BBQ Sun, 03/12/06 5:19 PM (permalink)

                          drewcarey,
                          I have seen bulgogi called barbecued beef yet when they describe and define all of their dishes, they call it grilled even when cooked over charcoal. http://www.lifeinkorea.com/cgi-bin/menu.cfm
                          Perhaps in California flat griddles are used in a Korean restaurant, but here in the Midwest there is often a gas fired conical set of cast iron plates in the center of the table that you use to cook your own meat or as in this Google picture, a Weber Grill type cooker. The flat griddles around here are common in Japanese type cooking.
                          I'm curious, do you Canon, Sharp, Ricoh or Toshiba a sheet of paper or do you xerox it?
                           
                          #13
                            stevencarry

                            • Total Posts: 359
                            • Joined: 2/18/2006
                            • Location: San Rafael, CA
                            RE: Correct Terms Fried,Grilled,BBQ Sun, 03/12/06 5:36 PM (permalink)
                            None Frank, I Lexmark it. You provided good info though and maybe BT can show authentic Korean in The City.
                             
                            #14
                              BuddyRoadhouse

                              • Total Posts: 3409
                              • Joined: 12/10/2004
                              • Location: Des Plaines, IL
                              RE: Correct Terms Fried,Grilled,BBQ Sun, 03/12/06 5:48 PM (permalink)
                              quote:
                              Originally posted by stevencarry

                              Buddy, if you fried an egg you would not have a half an inch of oil. What are you thinking? You would just have a "coating" of fat.
                              What I am thinking is that, like the terms "grill" and "barbecue", common usage has altered the strict definition of the word "fry". In my world, a fried egg is that in name only.
                              quote:
                              I thought to "saute" would be with some oil otherwise whenever you see cooking on flat cast iron www.lodgemfg.com like my reversible griddle/grill or probably most diners they are cooking on a surface that is never oiled,greased,or cleaned because that is how it works, the fat "seasons" the surface.
                              While the dictionary definition of "saute" is, "To fry quickly in a little fat," if you watch any of the chefs on PBS or the Food Network, saute's "in the know" meaning puts more emphasis on the amount of time spent on the process rather than the amount of oil used. Sauted, grilled (which are actually griddled), and caramelized onions are all fried in a "little" fat, and yet, all are radically different and certainly not interchangeable.

                              As for you assertion that the griddles in most diners are "never oiled, greased or cleaned," thus seasoning the surface, I would posit that you are only partially correct. Most diners' griddles are oiled regularly. Restaurant suppliers offer numerous brands specifically for this purpose. You are correct that the oil is not added prior to every item cooked on the griddle. That is because, as you state with your "seasoning" comment, that each time a burger, steak, chop, or whatever is cooked on the griddle it imparts it's own fats into the griddle's semi porous surface. Ask some of the many Waffle House fans we have on this site (not trying to pick a fight folks, but admit it, this is true), when they do cook an item with little or no inherent fats of its own (i.e., eggs, hash browns),they will in fact add a small amount of the aforementioned cooking oil to the griddle.
                              quote:
                              Buddy, no I have not read the crock/bbq. One is steaming, one is smoking, so I don't know how those two would go together.
                              We have no argument on this one. If I had wanted to join that battle I would have done so long ago on that thread. For a change, I choose to keep my mouth shut and let someone else enter the fray.

                              Speaking of which, where the heck are all you purists? Why hasn't anyone raised hell about the use of the words "crock pot" and "barbecue" in the same sentence. You're getting soft, all of you.
                              quote:
                              And I have only seen a giant griddle in a Korean place. In fact the only thing I think they should be known for
                              is "Kim Chee" everything else is run of the mill.
                              Finally, my friend, you need to be hanging out at a better class of Korean restaurant.

                              Korean cuisine is amazing, offering brilliant contrasts between cold and spicy, sweet and savory, and with a remarkable variety of textures and colors.

                              The method of cooking you have described above is more common, to me at least, under the name Mongolian Barbecue. Granted, it is no less inaccurate or misleading, but, one thing it ain't is Korean.

                              Here in Chicago a typical Korean Barbecue resataurant has large tables with a round, about 10"-12" diameter hole cut out of the middle. Thinly sliced meats are deliverd raw to your table with a variety of vegetables, relishes and condiments. A heavy duty metal bucket, about the size one would use for gardening purposes, filled with glowing charcoal is then set into the hole in the table. A prefitted grill (not a griddle; this has slots in it allowing for direct heat to meat contact) is placed on top of the bucket and the happy diners then place the meat and vegetables on the grill. If it's a really classy Korean restaurant, they will provide a server who will prepare the meal at your table.

                              You imply in a subsequent post that some folks are not taking this seriously. I can assure you I understand your frustration and do not wish to mock (that's what I'm thinking), however, I think you are creating your own pain here. My guess is that most of these errors are made out of ignorance, not an effort to deceive the buying public (most of whom don't know the difference either). I think you, as an enlightened consumer, knowing that this ignorance abounds, need to ask these questions before ordering.

                              If I walk into a typical diner or coffeshop and I see the word "barbecue" as part of an item's description, I know darn well, it ain't barbecued. On the other hand if I walk into a barbecue joint and I get something that clearly hasn't been barbecued, they will never see me again, and I will tell the world about said establishment's incompetence and deception (Open Pit Barbecue, 2 locations in west central Ohio; steer clear).

                              Bottom line here is, you can continue to let this make you nuts, and try to educate every restaurant owner in America who thinks he's serving "Barbecue", or you can ask the right questions before ordering and make the appropriate choices (something we failed to do at Open Pit Barbecue, 2 locations in west central Ohio; steer clear).

                              Good luck in your mission.

                              Buddy
                               
                              #15
                                MilwFoodlovers

                                • Total Posts: 2921
                                • Joined: 3/31/2001
                                • Location: Milwaukee, WI
                                RE: Correct Terms Fried,Grilled,BBQ Sun, 03/12/06 6:00 PM (permalink)
                                When I was a short order cook, my end of the day duty was to rub the grill (griddle to you) down with a brick shaped pumice stone.
                                 
                                #16
                                  stevencarry

                                  • Total Posts: 359
                                  • Joined: 2/18/2006
                                  • Location: San Rafael, CA
                                  RE: Correct Terms Fried,Grilled,BBQ Sun, 03/12/06 6:03 PM (permalink)
                                  This time I have to call you mister. Mr. Roadhouse, Excellent response.
                                   
                                  #17
                                    BuddyRoadhouse

                                    • Total Posts: 3409
                                    • Joined: 12/10/2004
                                    • Location: Des Plaines, IL
                                    RE: Correct Terms Fried,Grilled,BBQ Sun, 03/12/06 6:09 PM (permalink)
                                    Acknowledgement appreciated, hatchets buried.

                                    Seriously, don't let this thing make you crazy. Unless it's a real 'Que joint, don't expect the real thing.

                                    Go in peace and eat well.

                                    Buddy
                                     
                                    #18
                                      roossy90

                                      • Total Posts: 6694
                                      • Joined: 8/15/2005
                                      • Location: columbus, oh
                                      RE: Correct Terms Fried,Grilled,BBQ Sun, 03/12/06 7:26 PM (permalink)
                                      IMO

                                      Fry=anything cooked in oil

                                      Grill=score marks (electric or gas "grill")(like in restaurants)
                                      (flat top does not make it grilled or fried IMO-even though some places call it a grill-I call it a griddle)

                                      BBQ=wood burning or gas grill (outside)
                                      I probably forgot something, but.. oh well.
                                       
                                      #19
                                        Online Bookmarks Sharing: Share/Bookmark

                                        Jump to:

                                        Current active users

                                        There are 0 members and 1 guests.

                                        Icon Legend and Permission

                                        • New Messages
                                        • No New Messages
                                        • Hot Topic w/ New Messages
                                        • Hot Topic w/o New Messages
                                        • Locked w/ New Messages
                                        • Locked w/o New Messages
                                        • Read Message
                                        • Post New Thread
                                        • Reply to message
                                        • Post New Poll
                                        • Submit Vote
                                        • Post reward post
                                        • Delete my own posts
                                        • Delete my own threads
                                        • Rate post

                                        2000-2012 ASPPlayground.NET Forum Version 3.9
                                        What is Roadfood?  |   Privacy Policy  |   Contact Roadfood.com   Copyright 2011 - Roadfood.com