RE: Hocking Hills/Lancaster, OH
Here's what we found:
Mauger's Seafood, 512 West Main, Lancaster
Very traditional seafood place, broiled in butter/fried swordfish, scallops, shrimp, surf & turf, etc. Only sauces were tartar & cocktail - none of that coulis stuff at Mauger's! Plenty of halfway decent bottles of wine for under $20. Only drawback - no salad bar.
Would definitely go back, possibly even drive down from Columbus.