I just came back from a trip to Central NY and the Adirondacks for my mom's wedding and we all had a fantastic time! I took Amtrak from Penn Station to Rome, NY and had a very quiet, peaceful ride on a train that was only half full, so I snagged two seats for myself. Harold (mom's fiancee) picked me up and we headed out to meet mom at Teddy's Restaurant for dinner.
Wednesday September 17-Day 1
Today's specials.
I started with the cream of broccoli soup. I hadn't cared for it on my last visit, but this was pretty good; creamy and with big chunks of broccoli.
Harold had the Beef Burgundy Stew and switched the mashed potatoes out for cavatappi pasta.
I opted for the Roast Turkey Dinner. It was just okay. I liked the creamy mashed potatoes, but I don't think the turkey was fresh roasted right off the bird. The stuffing was a few steps up from Stove Top and the veggies (peas, corn, orange peppers and green beans) were somewhat lacking in flavor. I was disappointed as I really wanted to like this meal as I have loved so many at Teddy's.
The dessert menu. I was so intrigued by the "Southern Cheese Pie", that I HAD to order it.
I asked the staff what was in the cheese pie and they said they didn't think there was cheese in it, but there was definitely chocolate in it. When this came out, I immediately thought of CajunKing's Chocolate Chess Pie on the recent "All the pies I've loved before" thread. I'm pretty sure that this is a chess pie and someone thought that "chess" couldn't have possibly been the right name. It was dense and slightly chewy, had raisins in it and a homemade crust. It was a pretty good piece of pie and I'd get it again. I think the next time I'm here for dinner though, I'll stick with their specialties like Chicken Riggies and chicken parmesean.
1.) Teddy's Restaurant
851 Black River Boulevard North
Rome, NY 13440
Phone # 315-336-7839
Website:
www.teddysrestaurantny.com Roadfood review:
http://www.roadfood.com/Reviews/Overview.aspx?RefID=4381 Thursday September 18-Day 2
The next day we picked up my girlfriend at the train station and headed to Nicky Doodles for lunch. My mom has said a lot of good things about this place, so I've been eager to try it. 50 flavors of custard? I'm so there!
Doesn't look like a lot of character from the outside, but they have lots of great CNY specialties!
Hot Ham is one of the foods I grew up loving to eat.
Lots of outdoor seating, but it was a bit windy, so we opted for inside.
The menu. Part 1... I'd love to wrap my lips around a Nicky Burger next time!
Part 2... So many CNY ice cream stands/sandwich stands offer Hot Ham and/or BBQ sandwiches. More on the Hot Ham in a bit. The BBQ sandwiches usually consist of simmered meats (beef, ham, turkey or pork) served on a roll that differs from place to place and covered in sauce or served with sauce on the side. Very difficult to find in the fall as most places that serve them close once the leaves start changing colors.
and Part 3. Macaroni and potato salads can be found on many CNY menus in the summertime.
They even have a nod to the Rochester Roadfood favorite, Nick Tahou's, with a Dumpster plate.
And a close-up of the Dumpster plate. They toast their hot dog buns as the bread to go with it.
Mom had grilled veggies as her side. Note: these are "grilled" on a flat-top griddle, not a charcoal grill.
Mom's Bacon Cheeseburger. I love that they butter and toast the buns here and the quality of that bun looks top notch.
My gf's Chicken Pita with french fries. You can't really see much of the chicken in this shot, but it is there.
My Hot Ham sandwich with french fries. This was REALLY good! Lots of moist, spicy capicola ham with a heat that lingered on the lips for a while. The roll was soft in a good way, but was also shored up by buttering and toasting. I don't think they are doing hand cut fries here, but they are pretty good.
The two BBQ sauces on the side. Gold sauce and the regular red sauce. The red was spicy and smoky, not really my thing. The gold was awesome though as it was spicy and sweet and complemented the ham very well. These came from two large squirtable sauce jars, so I don't think they are homemade, but I like that they have the option of letting me decide how much sauce I want.
Lots of indoor picnic tables.
Some of the 50's style tables.
The next few shots are of the listing of the many ice cream, custard, soft serve and sundaes that they offer.
The #12 and #24 have my name written all over them!
I went for a small butterscotch soft custard with toasted coconut flakes.
The custard was very creamy and had a wonderful butterscotch note to it. The toasted coconut was actually a sauce that hardened up like Magic Shell. The texture was nice, but it was way too sugary sweet and got in the way of the pure flavor of the custard.
We dropped my mom off at the salon to get her nails done and stopped in at the Gourmet Garden Cafe next door to check things out. It's part of a really neat gift shop with lots of things that are Rome-centric called Utopia.
They had different flavors of gelato that I wasn't too impressed with. Some had a gummy texture and the roasted pistachio nuts were too soft.
On my last trip up here, I noticed Papa Rick's, but didn't have a chance to stop in, so I just had to check it out this time.
This is another seasonal shack and they're open until the first week of October.
The menu. We didn't get to meet Papa Rick, but his dad, Papa Bob, was working there today. I asked him about the place and he said that they are firemen and the theme runs throughout the menu. Sorry about the photo quality, but I couldn't get a good shot without the reflections. On the menu, they have the Extinguish Your Thirst with Drinks from the Hydrant section, Infernos (instead of Blizzards), the Hook & Ladder Parfait, Dalmation Parfait, Stop, Drop & Roll with a Banana Split and Firehouse Chili to name a few!
This is the sign that piqued my interest in August. It's another firefighter's reference and it includes fries, slaw and a roll.
Hofmann hot dogs, fried dough, fried brownies and cheesecake and BBQ sandwiches and soft serve? What's not to like? Sadly, we didn't get anything to eat as we had just come from Nicky Doodles and were stuffed. We talked to Papa Bob for a bit and he was a real nice guy! I hope to make it there next summer.
I never knew they had names, so I was very glad to see this sign. It gives Hofmanns a lot more character!
Dayna and I had some time to kill before picking up my mom, so we took a self-guided tour of the Fort Stanwix National Monument. I hadn't been here since I was a kid and was eager to see it again, especially after they opened up a new visitor's center. The Mystery, Myth & Mayhem sounds like my kind of tour. We had fun walking through the fort, but I think that it would have been much more interesting and informative to go on a guided tour. I'll let the signs in the pics tell most of the story.
Here is a bit of Fort Stanwix history (taken from the National Park Service website): Known as "the fort that never surrendered," Fort Stanwix, under the command of Col. Peter Gansevoort, successfully repelled a prolonged siege, in August 1777, by British, German, Loyalist, Canadian and American Indian troops and warriors commanded British Gen. Barry St. Leger. The failed siege combined with the battles at Oriskany, Bennington, and Saratoga thwarted a coordinated effort by the British in 1777, under the leadership of Gen. John Burgoyne, to take the northern colonies, and led to American alliances with France and the Netherlands. Troops from Fort Stanwix also participated in the 1779 Clinton-Sullivan Campaign and protected America's northwest frontier from British campaigns until finally abandoned in 1781.
The next four shots are of upcoming events that were posted in the visitor's center.
The walkway to the fort. The row of buildings off in the distance on the right are in the area known as Little Italy (East Dominick Street). There used to be many Italian men's social clubs, restaurants and meat markets down there. The Plaza Restaurant is one such place that still exists and serves up some killer Chicken Riggies, chicken parm and garlic pizza. Rome is also home to the World Series of Bocce every summer.
A shot of the fort. It was tough to get an all encompassing shot of it, so the second shot below this one gives a better idea of how the fort looks from above.
The entrance to the fort.
And an overhead view.
This sunken area around the fort was designed to keep potential invaders exposed should they try to breach the fort. The spikes coming out from the exterior walls are there to prevent ladders from being propped up on the walls and making the fort more easily defendable.
Based on the beds, people seemed to be much shorter back then.
The bastions ensured that the troops could see potential invaders coming and created a higher ground position from which they could defend the fort.
This is actually TWO fireplaces. Pretty cool.
I look at this and I think, lives were discussed around this fireplace, the future was planned. It would be very interesting to sit in on those conversations and hear how much or how little the country has changed since then.
WHAT!! I slept until the 21st century? EGAD! What is that iron eagle in the sky? There is a lot of history in this picture for me. I slept in this bed about 25 years ago with my scout troop. My dad and I came to the fort with the Boy Scouts and lived like the Revolutionaries did for a night. We made beef stew and biscuits over an open fire and listened to stories of what life was like at the fort in the 18th century. A pretty cool experience. The fort smells just like I remember (in a good way).
Exiting the fort.
I've always loved this house. I just think it's beautiful.
When we went to pick up mom at the salon, I saw this on the door. Figures, I move outta Rome and all the dang yodelers just move right on in!!
Outside Coalyard Charlie's. Not much has changed in this place in the last 25 years. There is a lot of history to this building. It started out as a general store and boarding house on the Erie Canal more than 150 years ago and has been a restaurant for more than 50 years (taken from their website).
The hours.
The salad bar here is okay. Nothing fancy, just your standard iceberg lettuce and a few toppings options. I opted for the French dressing, which I haven't had in years and it was as thick as I remembered. In the time it took for the dressing to get from the ladle to my salad plate, I did my taxes, ran the Boilermaker Road Race, and toured the Baseball Hall of Fame in Cooperstown!!
Can you believe it??!! I HAD to try this!
It was pretty good. They really nailed the flavor of the riggies.
My salad.
Cheddar bread. Something I grew up on for years when I lived in Rome. I don't know how recently they've served it here, but there used to be a grocery store called Gillette's and my family always bought a loaf of cheddar bread to have in the house. It made great toast and was perfect for cold cut sandwiches. Especially when they made their jalapeno-cheddar bread! Coalyard's bread was really good and complemented the meal quite nicely.
Dayna's steak and shrimp with a baked potato.
My steak and scallops with a baked potato. The scallops were tender and swimming in butter and lemon juice and the potato was very tender. My family and I have been coming here since I can remember and I've always had a great meal, especially steak. It's not a touristy place and I always know I'll run into 3 or 4 people I know between the bar and the dining room. It's one of my uncle's favorite places to eat and we usually get him a gift certificate for Christmas.
Look at that crusty beef!
Cooked medium and to perfection. Juicy, tender, nice crust and it didn't require anything but my appetite.
My Coconut Cream Pie. It was okay. The thing I didn't care for about this is that the texture seemed droopy. It wasn't runny, but the custard and the whipped cream sagged a great deal. I might order it again in the hope that this was just an abberation.
The crust on this was definitely homemade and had a flaky, buttery quality to it.
My mom's warm Toll House Pie with vanilla ice cream. I didn't try it, but it sure looked good.
1.) Nicky Doodles
1159 Erie Boulevard West
Rome, NY 13440
Phone # 315-339-5395
No website
2.) Cornucopia Candles & Toy Shoppe and the Gourmet Garden Cafe
2051 North Madison Street
Rome, NY 13440
Phone # 315-336-8059
Website:
http://www.cornucopiacandles.com/ 3.) Papa Rick's Snack Shack
2005 North James Street
Rome, NY 13440
Phone # 315-339-2622
No website
Open 11am to 11pm, 7 days a week until Oct. 4th. Not clear if they close for the season at that point.
4.) Fort Stanwix National Monument
112 East Park Street
Rome, NY 13440
Phone # 315-338-7730
Website:
http://www.nps.gov/fost/index.htm 5.) Coalyard Charlie's
100 Depeyster Street
Rome, NY 13440
Phone # 315-336-9940
Website:
www.coalyardcharlies.com COMING UP ON Day 3 and 4...my first "headlight" in years, off to the Adirondack Mountains for some great Italian food (and character) to match, a hit & miss breakfast, a trip to my most favorite store, Old Forge Hardware and spending time up in Big Moose and cruising on Raquette Lake for my mom's wedding!! STAY TUNED......