Unfortunately, even though it wasn't that late in the day, they only had four types of pie left: coconut cream, custard, sugar cream and chocolate.
For some reason, I remembered their being a fruit pie choice - maybe strawberry-rhubarb? Or was that somewhere else? I hope that I am not skipping ahead in the story, but the following day we were out and about in Columbus. During one of our stops, we called ChiTownDiner
to tell him about some of adventures, including our stop at Henry's. He had asked which pies we tried, and I told him that there were only four remaining options when we arrived. He was genuinely disappointed when we told him that we did not just order one of each. I kinda felt like we let him down!