"I told my sister I thought they were smaller, but she said the same thing...we were small, too! I have a "loving" term for these mints...gagalicious! They are so sweet, they are creamy, and they have a lot of flavor."
Well, that may be the case, but heck I wasn't that small. I was in my teens. Anyway, I think they're pretty darn close. I just found them a little bit chewier then I recalled, but as RubyRose suggested it could have been they were on the shelf longer.
Funniest thing, I thought I'd ordered two boxes and after I finished the "first" one, I couldn't find the second one. I asked my husband who said he'd torn the box up for the garbage, but didn't see it. I ran out to the recycle can, almost dove down into it till I found all the pieces of the box and stuffings, but didn't find the candy. Came back in the house, got my invoice and saw that I had only ordered 1 box!! I was crushed. Guess I'll have to order more than 1 at a time next go around.
Sorry, can't help you with the Eskimo Pie. I do remember them from the "old days" complete with the ice cream man etc., but don't remember them as being round at least in Virginia. Good luck on your search, and yes it's been a blast. Hope we run across each other again on another search.
Think they should just have a special section on these forums for searching foods.