Knockum Hill in Herndon, Ky

Post
Poverty Pete
Double Chili Cheeseburger
2006/08/28 19:46:21

Louis mentioned this place a few days ago and I picked up on his description of a massive pork chop I arranged to meet up with him on Saturday at Knockum Hill. The outside of the building is very inviting.


When we got inside, the menu was brief, to the point and very inexpensive. Note the $0.75 anything you want to drink. What catches your eye is that their pork chop is priced higher than the ribs.



I had already been tipped as to the chop. I made an entire day trip for this chop. I was not disappointed. I have had many one pound pork chops in Indiana, Illinois, and Iowa, but this behemoth is in a category by itself, unless you've been to the Big Texan, in Amarillo, and ordered (or seen) the 72 oz. monster.



It was cooked perfectly. There was a half-inch smoke ring, but not the least sign of drying out, which I totally expected. I'll remember this plate for a long long time.

Now for the downside. The sides were not up to par. The baked beans, I believe, came out of a can, without much imagination devoted to them afterwards. Louis liked the burgoo, but it had so many lima beans, I couldn't taste anything else.
I sampled the pulled pork, but wasn't impressed. The sauce was OK, but not inspired. Fortunately, I had a bottle of Trolinger's bbq sauce in my saddlebags, that saved the sandwich.
All in all, it's a great place, but a one trick pony.
mayor al
Fire Safety Admin
RE: Knockum Hill in Herndon, Ky 2006/08/28 20:05:33
Note this post contains most of a post by LOUIS on the Where do I eat Forum about Western KY and Indiana BBQ.

LOUIS is Answering a question about the KNOCKUM HILL BBQ--


Pete, A few miles below Hopkinsville, there is a place called Knockum Hill Bar B Que. It's address is: 11185 Highway 107 South, Herndon, Kentucky 42236; Phone: (270) 271-2957.
They have WEIRD hours. Try this:
Friday 9 a.m. to 6 p.m.
Saturday 9 a.m. to 3 p.m.
That's it!

When I arrived, I drove into the driveway of some guy's house. Off to the side of his home is his barbecue restaurant, which has a handful of tables inside. Behind his restaurant is a very large pavillion with maybe 40 picnic tables for large gatherings.
Knockum Hill does a large take out business. I realized why later. The food is good, but their portions are humongous.

I was told to order the BBQ pork chop, which I did. When they brought it to my table, although I was told it would be large, I was still unprepared for how large it was. The pork chop had to be at least 4 inches thick and 6 inches wide. I wish I had a tape measure, but I know I'm very close in my calculations.

The taste? Well, it's mild. It reminds me of Tennessee barbecue, which is generally milder than what I am used to in the northwest corner of Kentucky. It needed a little sauce, but only a touch. (And it was good sauce, I might add. Thin, but very tasty.)

But the pork chop's most enduring quality was how juicy it was. In my experience, a pork chop is usually kind of dry. This had to be the juiciest pork chop I ever put in my mouth. Butter tender. Very flavorful. Juice drizzling down my chin. I could only eat a third of it. It was just too large to eat in one sitting.

I got a barbecue pork sandwich to go, which I ate the next day. If anything, that sandwich had more flavor than the pork chop.

Apparently, the restaurant is a sort of glorified hobby for the guy who runs the place. Something for him to do on weekends. But boy, what a hobby, and well done!

ADD from Al--Knockum Hill (Herndon) is a few miles off I-24 at Exit 86 (US 41A) North side of Fort Campbell.
xannie_01
Double Chili Cheeseburger
RE: Knockum Hill in Herndon, Ky 2006/08/28 20:07:24
the hubster wants me to post his
reaction..
"I WANT ONE OF THEM!!!!!!!!!!!!!"
my reaction "they expect you to eat it with that fork???"" />
dayle
Oneiron339
Double Chili Cheeseburger
RE: Knockum Hill in Herndon, Ky 2006/08/28 20:48:13
I'd try it, but now since I'm a dipsydoodledoublehamburgerdog or whatever, make it a double
mayor al
Fire Safety Admin
RE: Knockum Hill in Herndon, Ky 2006/08/29 12:18:25

I can visualize a gathering like the one last February, with about 50 Hungry Roadfooders all ordering the 'Pork Chop Sandwich'. If we were to start a rumor about this activity it might have a direct impact on the current price of "Hog Futures" on the Chicago Commodity Market!
Louis
Double Cheeseburger
RE: Knockum Hill in Herndon, Ky 2006/08/29 14:39:29
Al, maybe we ought to organize a future gathering in order to test that theory out.

By the way, what Poverty Pete said above about my liking their burgoo is true--up to a point. I was pouring on nearly every mouthful of it the Trolinger's barbecue sauce that he had brought with him. With that wonderful sauce on it, the burgoo was--of course!--very good! By itself it was decent but average. I think Pete got far more lima beans than I did in his burgoo. My portion didn't seem to have that many limas in it. Funny how a turn of the spoon the wrong way can cause differing perceptions. Pete made a fan out of me with that barbecue sauce, though. I ordered some for myself after our meeting. I could douse that stuff on all sorts of things that have nothing to do with barbecue! That evening I had some better burgoo at George's BBQ in Owensboro. For me, that's burgoo's gold standard.
SurrealGourmet
Hamburger
RE: Knockum Hill in Herndon, Ky 2006/08/29 18:01:09
quote:
Originally posted by Louis
Pete made a fan out of me with that barbecue sauce, though. I ordered some for myself after our meeting.


How did you order the sauce? I ran out of mine about 3 months ago and have really missed it. I always use it when I smoke a shoulder.
Poverty Pete
Double Chili Cheeseburger
RE: Knockum Hill in Herndon, Ky 2006/08/29 21:30:23
If you google Trolinger's in Paris Tn., you'll find their web page. Their sauce is like Arthur Bryant's, but I think even better.
SurrealGourmet
Hamburger
RE: Knockum Hill in Herndon, Ky 2006/08/30 14:44:56
Apparently their website doesn't exist anymore.
Sundancer7
Fire Safety Admin
RE: Knockum Hill in Herndon, Ky 2006/08/30 16:37:26
The chop is way too huge for me to enjoy but it sure looks good.

Paul E. Smith
Knoxville, TN
Pwingsx
Double Chili Cheeseburger
RE: Knockum Hill in Herndon, Ky 2006/08/30 17:10:45
Do they ship?
mayor al
Fire Safety Admin
RE: Knockum Hill in Herndon, Ky 2006/08/30 17:57:47
Yes, They do ship.
Trolinger's BBQ and Butcher Shop
2305 East Wood Street, Paris, TN 38242
731-642-8667
Hours: Monday - Saturday, 7 a.m. - 6 p.m./7 p.m. DST; Sunday 9 a.m. - 6 p.m./7p.m. DST A family tradition since 1917.



http://tn-humanities.org/community/articles/kitour.php
Sundancer7
Fire Safety Admin
RE: Knockum Hill in Herndon, Ky 2006/08/30 18:49:36
Sure does sound good to me. I think I will go there.

Paul E. Smith
knoxville, TN
Poverty Pete
Double Chili Cheeseburger
RE: Knockum Hill in Herndon, Ky 2006/08/30 19:15:33
The website exists, and they do ship.
http://tonga.globat.com/~trolingers.com/home.html
pcdiva
Double Cheeseburger
RE: Knockum Hill in Herndon, Ky 2006/08/31 06:02:05
Okey-doke, count me in. Also reserve a space for Mom-diva. She'll go wherever I take her! Wow, what a hunk of pork critter!!!!!

Alice
SurrealGourmet
Hamburger
RE: Knockum Hill in Herndon, Ky 2006/08/31 09:16:53
Thank you, Poverty Pete! I tried that address yesterday and it kept telling me that domain name had expired. I will be ordering me some BBQ sauce now!! I have relatives that live right by Trolinger's and have eaten their BBQ on many occasions. Thanks again for the link.
pcdiva
Double Cheeseburger
RE: Knockum Hill in Herndon, Ky 2006/09/02 09:41:38
That's not a pork chop, that's a small rib ROAST!!!!! So Al, when's the next Glee Club meeting in Herndon???? Have to plan my social calendar, don't 'cha know.
CajunKing
Sirloin
RE: Knockum Hill in Herndon, Ky 2006/09/15 12:46:13
Have we set a date yet?????????

I am starving and stuck in the office right now with no chance of anything decent to eat.

I tried licking the puter moniter but that didnt help any
Poverty Pete
Double Chili Cheeseburger
RE: Knockum Hill in Herndon, Ky 2006/09/15 22:35:09
Cajunking, the place isn't big enough for a real RF outing, but let me know when you want to go, and I'll arrange to hook up with you.
MikeS.
Fire Safety Admin
RE: Knockum Hill in Herndon, Ky 2006/09/16 02:14:04
"Behind his restaurant is a very large pavillion with maybe 40 picnic tables for large gatherings."

I should think that this many tables should accomadate us all???

MikeS.
Poverty Pete
Double Chili Cheeseburger
RE: Knockum Hill in Herndon, Ky 2006/09/16 07:14:46
Actually, Mike, you're probably right. There's plenty of seating. We would just have to warn him we were coming, so he wouldn't run out of food.
Louis
Double Cheeseburger
RE: Knockum Hill in Herndon, Ky 2006/09/16 16:22:10
We would have to have a gathering when the weather is warm. Pete's right. The building couldn't accommodate one of our Roadfood gatherings. We'd have to use the pavillion out back. I think everyone would enjoy it. I'm going to get down there again soon, before the weather gets cold. I'd be interested to hear what those who have made the pilgrimage there thought of it.
Big_g
Cheeseburger
RE: Knockum Hill in Herndon, Ky 2006/09/19 23:09:50
PovertyPete,
based on this statement "sauce in my saddlebags" are you a motorcyclist???
mayor al
Fire Safety Admin
RE: Knockum Hill in Herndon, Ky 2006/09/20 02:16:32
Big g....
Nah, He rides an old Mule around , kinda like"Marryin' Sam" did!!

(Just kidding-Here he is!)


Big_g
Cheeseburger
RE: Knockum Hill in Herndon, Ky 2006/09/20 13:41:11
Its a great way to enjoy two passions. I try to ride my Wing everywhere I can.
improviser
Double Cheeseburger
RE: Knockum Hill in Herndon, Ky 2006/09/20 16:59:48
That's a great looking Wing, Big G.

I'd love to come to a Roadfood get together at Knockum Hill. I've got family in KY. Plus I've been lurking on these boards for a long time (years and years and I'm still a Cheeseburger) and have never met any Roadfooders.
Poverty Pete
Double Chili Cheeseburger
RE: Knockum Hill in Herndon, Ky 2006/09/20 19:44:36
Big-g, will you take me for a ride in your sidecar? I get over by Sweetwater at least once a month or so. Is that bbq joint near the interstate any good?
Big_g
Cheeseburger
RE: Knockum Hill in Herndon, Ky 2006/09/20 23:44:30
I'd be glad to Pete! It is currently off the bike (its only four bolts)kinda short on garage space.
Which BBQ joint? Bradley's..just..ok...some times you can taste starter on the meat Or Uncle Johns...tried their take out meat was ok...sides were barely sides.
I like mine best....



If all goes well, the weather holds, and I get a kitchen pass...I'm going to meet some Wing friends at the Church of the Holy Smoke...New Zion Missionary Babtist Church in Huntsville, TX on the 30th and when I get back I'll add some photos to the BBQ Porn site :)
Louis
Double Cheeseburger
RE: Knockum Hill in Herndon, Ky 2007/03/24 22:25:29
I dined at Knockum Hill Bar B-Q in Herndon, Kentucky today. It was the first time I had been down there since Poverty Pete and I ate there last summer. It's a good 100-mile drive for me.

I tried their ribs today; they were fair. The enormous pork chop is still the star attraction at this place. Their pork chop is now $10.50--up $1.00 from a year ago. It's still a steal. You'd have to pay $30 or more in any other place for the amount of food they give you. (And that rib was as huge as the pork chop, but easier to consume.)

The owners said they had resisted raising the price of the pork chop for years, but they finally gave in to rising meat prices. They may have to raise the price of some of their other items eventually. Still, for the enormous portions that diners receive, the prices border on the ridiculous. They'll get no complaints from me.

If you missed visiting this place last year, put it on your list for new places to visit this year. You won't be sorry.
Poverty Pete
Double Chili Cheeseburger
RE: Knockum Hill in Herndon, Ky 2007/03/24 23:24:18
Louis, it's interesting that you went there today. Just this evening I was pondering taking a ride there tomorrow with a friend or two, but not sure whether it would be open. Did you happen to notice Sunday hours?
The price increase in the pork chop is immaterial. If they charged $15, I wouldn't care. This chop is big enough to be lunch for two, plus one or two small children.

Never mind. I reread the original posts. Guess I'll try for next Saturday.
Louis
Double Cheeseburger
RE: Knockum Hill in Herndon, Ky 2007/03/25 09:07:25
Pete, I guess you'll have to try for next Saturday. Just get there early. Remember what happened to us when we went there: the place closed at 1:15 in the afternoon because the diners had eaten all their wares. I got there at noon and it was deserted, but by 12:30 it was beginning to fill up.
pharmerphil
Junior Burger
RE: Knockum Hill in Herndon, Ky 2008/01/20 12:00:10
Made my first trip to Knockumhill BBQ (even though it's only an hours drive,50 miles,from my home)this past Friday. The "porkchop" (in actuality, a 3 lb., 4-rib bone, 5 inch, pork rib-roast)was all it had been touted here at Roadfood, and more! When I picked-up my lunch at the counter, and see this monstrosity sitting on a paper plate with a plastic fork & knife, I'm dubious as to how I'm going to cut the thing. Well, no need to worry! It was absoulutely "pull-apart" tender, moist & juicy, beyond all expectations. Great smoky flavor and my wife & I split the thing & had about a half lb. of meat left over. We are NOT lightweights & have healthy appetites (maybe not HEALTHY appetites, but large appetites). I know Patti's at Grand Rivers, Ky., has a reputation for their porkchops but they aren't in the same league as the one served here at Knockemhill. Got another one "to go" for a friend & he was as impressed as I was. Brought home 2 lbs. of their pulled-pork and we thought it was VERY good also. The sauce they baste & cook with, is a lard based vinegar, lemon juice, salt & seasonings concoction which I think is better than the standard red, ketchup based sauce. Been living in the South for all 62 yrs. of my life, eaten at about every BBQ restaurant I could find, and this particular place is outstanding. The owners were very friendly & cordial. If you get the chance to visit Knockumhill, try the porkchop($10.75) & I think (and hope) you will be as pleased & amazed as we were with it. OUTSTANDING!
mayor al
Fire Safety Admin
RE: Knockum Hill in Herndon, Ky 2008/01/20 12:15:06
Phil,
Thanks for the update on Knockum Hill. I'm glad to know they are holding their own with tha monster "Chop" !
Louis
Double Cheeseburger
RE: Knockum Hill in Herndon, Ky 2008/01/21 09:05:45
I'm glad you enjoyed it! As soon as it gets a little warmer, I'm going to have to get down there again. When I was last there one day around noon last June, I ate 3/4 of the chop (my record so far). Maybe I would have eaten the whole thing if I hadn't eaten at Charlie's Steak House (a handful of miles away) the evening before.
Poverty Pete
Double Chili Cheeseburger
RE: Knockum Hill in Herndon, Ky 2008/01/21 18:34:01
I have yet to eat even half a chop there. So, basically it's all you can eat for $10.75.
carolina bob
Filet Mignon
RE: Knockum Hill in Herndon, Ky 2010/05/20 22:44:51
I'm afraid that I have bad news. While Googling restaurants for an upcoming roadtrip to western Kentucky, I discovered that Knockum Hill BBQ burned to the ground on Feb. 25th of this year. As far as I can tell, the place hasn't been rebuilt and there are apparently no plans to do so.
Louis
Double Cheeseburger
RE: Knockum Hill in Herndon, Ky 2010/05/20 23:37:18
This place is over 100 miles from me, so maybe why that's why I hadn't heard anything about it.  I was surprised when Carolina Bob told me about it.

I'm going to ask and see if there is any chance of that luscious giant pork chop being resurrected somewhere else.  That thing was easily worth a 100 mile drive.

Here is the link that I think Bob first saw.  There are also two brief audio links with the firefighters.

http://www.wkdzradio.com/pages/6445667.php

Here are some photos from the fire.

http://www.wkdzradio.com/pages/6445625.php?

Looking around a little more, I found one other report about the fire, and in it was revealed that the owner intends to rebuild it.

http://webcache.googleuse...&ct=clnk&gl=us

So there is hope, roadfooders, there is hope that one day we might once again ascend to Pork Chop Hill and sink our teeth into one of the sweetest pieces of meat ever to exist on the planet.

post edited by Louis - 2010/05/20 23:58:04
carolina bob
Filet Mignon
RE: Knockum Hill in Herndon, Ky 2010/05/21 00:29:20
Louis, I'm glad that you did more research than I did, and it's nice to know that Mr. Hill intends to rebuild. I was looking forward to sampling that porcine colossus next month, but it looks like I'm just going to have to be patient for a while. 
ayersian
Double Cheeseburger
RE: Knockum Hill in Herndon, Ky 2010/05/21 00:55:40
Hey Pete and Louis!  Imagine the size of the biscuit required to sheathe THAT chop.  Takes the term "cat head" to a ridiculous level!    Chris
buffetbuster
Porterhouse
RE: Knockum Hill in Herndon, Ky 2010/05/21 08:05:19
What a shame to hear about the fire, but I am relieved to see that they are going to rebuild.  Louis took Ceci and I to Knockum Hill last year.  The food and atmosphere lived up to everything we had heard.
pharmerphil
Junior Burger
RE: Knockum Hill in Herndon, Ky 2010/05/21 09:14:08
Thanks to Carolina Bob, & all of you. that shared this info. about Knockum Hills burning down. I live only 50 miles away and wasn't aware about the fire. Really going to miss that huge porkchop & hope that they do rebuild and SOON.
Louis
Double Cheeseburger
RE: Knockum Hill in Herndon, Ky 2010/05/21 11:22:07
I emailed my dinner detective friend near Hopkinsville, Kentucky this morning,
and this is what he said about Knockum Hill:

Yes, the place was completely destroyed by a fire, but I think they are
starting to rebuild. There was an article in the newspaper a couple
weeks ago. I'll let you know more progress when I can find out. Many
of us anxiously await their reopening.
pharmerphil
Junior Burger
RE: Knockum Hill in Herndon, Ky 2010/10/25 12:56:03
Has anyone heard any more news about Knockum Hill rebuilding after being destroyed by the fire? I certainly hope they do rebuild!
carolina bob
Filet Mignon
RE: Knockum Hill in Herndon, Ky 2010/10/25 20:15:26
Knockum Hill BBQ is, I'm very happy to say, alive and well. Louis took me there back in June, and the amazing colossal porkchop that made the place famous definitely lives up to its lofty reputation. 
pharmerphil
Junior Burger
RE: Knockum Hill in Herndon, Ky 2010/10/25 20:37:59
Carolina Bob, Thanks for the quick answer with the good news! I'll share it with other friends that were wondering about its status. Thanks again.
Davwud
Double Cheeseburger
RE: Knockum Hill in Herndon, Ky 2010/10/26 17:28:41
Can anyone confirm hours?? Are they still the same limited ones posted upstream or are they open more now??
 
Is this place seasonal at all??
 
DT
carolina bob
Filet Mignon
RE: Knockum Hill in Herndon, Ky 2010/10/26 18:59:12
To my knowledge, Knockum Hill's schedule is the same as it was back in June: Friday 9am to 7pm, and Saturday 9am to 3pm. I don't know whether the place is seasonal or not, though. 
pharmerphil
Junior Burger
RE: Knockum Hill in Herndon, Ky 2010/10/26 19:13:58
I have not been to Knockum Hills since it burned back in Feb. What I found to work in the past, to avoid the "we're out of the big porkchop", was to call them on Thurs. afternoon (1-270-271-2957) and reserve one or two of the chops in your name. When I got there on Fri. they always had mine waiting & I saw other walk-in customers get the "we're out of them". This might save some of you a wasted trip to try one of these outstanding porkchops.
Davwud
Double Cheeseburger
RE: Knockum Hill in Herndon, Ky 2010/10/27 08:13:45
pharmerphil

I have not been to Knockum Hills since it burned back in Feb. What I found to work in the past, to avoid the "we're out of the big porkchop", was to call them on Thurs. afternoon (1-270-271-2957) and reserve one or two of the chops in your name. When I got there on Fri. they always had mine waiting & I saw other walk-in customers get the "we're out of them". This might save some of you a wasted trip to try one of these outstanding porkchops.

I had intended to call. My biggest problem is I will be just passing through on a long journey and would have a hard time pinning down when I'd be there.
 
Worth a shot though.
 
BTW I found the hours on another site. They're as advertised.
 
Thanks
DT
Louis
Double Cheeseburger
RE: Knockum Hill in Herndon, Ky 2010/10/27 23:56:24
When they reopened this summer after their fire, I was one of the very first customers.  They have never disappointed me.  It's about a 100-mile drive for me (one way) but that giant pork chop is always worth it.


Art Deco
Double Cheeseburger
RE: Knockum Hill in Herndon, Ky 2012/02/18 15:57:48
mayor al

I can visualize a gathering like the one last February, with about 50 Hungry Roadfooders all ordering the 'Pork Chop Sandwich'. If we were to start a rumor about this activity it might have a direct impact on the current price of "Hog Futures" on the Chicago Commodity Market!

Well, this has now come to pass, though there were only about 10 of us in attendance.  Everything reported previously about that chop is still true, except that the price of the plate is now up to $14.50 (and is still a steal).  I expect that there will be visual evidence in the Nashville "Glee Club" thread.  Suffice it to say that this has to be seen to truly be appreciated!
mayor al
Fire Safety Admin
RE: Knockum Hill in Herndon, Ky 2012/02/21 05:57:35
It was an interesting stop. The owner and his workers were very cooperative and friendly. The Chop is indeed 'GIANT'--think in terms of a 4 rib (bone-in) Pork Rib Roast, and you have a better descriptor. Ours had a nice crusty exterior, and very moist and juicy/tender interior. Flavor was good. I like my BBQ Pork to be fairly 'Smokey' and this was pretty mild, so I would rate it a 6 or maybe a 7 on the Mayor's 10 scale.  The sides were a mixed batch. I agree the BBBQ Beans were basic canned beans with a strong shot of brown sugar added. The potato salad was Supermarket deli-style...we didn't try anything else.
  The Knock'em Hill BBQ, is unique. If we were traveling up or down I24 for some reason, or visiting someone at Ft Campbell, KY, we might choose to stop again. But in reality, this was a one time visit to test a BBQ oddity.

Art Deco
Double Cheeseburger
RE: Knockum Hill in Herndon, Ky 2012/02/21 17:51:16
mayor al
The sides were a mixed batch. I agree the BBBQ Beans were basic canned beans with a strong shot of brown sugar added. The potato salad was Supermarket deli-style...we didn't try anything else.

I tried the burgoo, but one bite was enough.  Not very good...
Louis
Double Cheeseburger
RE: Knockum Hill in Herndon, Ky 2012/02/21 19:38:01
I've tried all their sides.  Not a one of them is worth writing about.  The pork chop, the ribs, and the barbecue is all you want.  Indeed, I don't know why they even bother with the sides.
 
post edited by Louis - 2012/02/21 19:48:21