LockedGary, Indiana was first with Pizza

Page: 12 > Showing page 1 of 2
Post
Polish guy
Cheeseburger
2006/11/08 11:20:45
Gary, Indiana was the first or second in the U.S.A. to make and sell, Pizza. It was great. Do any of you remember this? Tell me of your eating Pizza in Gary, Indiana, in the 40's and 50's, for the old timers.
saps
Double Chili Cheeseburger
RE: Gary, Indiana was first with Pizza 2006/11/08 11:36:38
They were selling it in New York and CT far before that.
Polish guy
Cheeseburger
RE: Gary, Indiana was first with Pizza 2006/11/11 10:59:53
Says who?

Anyway for sure in all the midwest.
dholk
Cheeseburger
RE: Gary, Indiana was first with Pizza 2006/11/11 11:17:19
Polish Guy,

You've said before that the first American pizza started in Gary, Indiana. This must have been before 1905, when Lombardi's started in New York.

Do you have any more information about pizza in Gary around 1900? I haven't been able to find any information on the internet.

Searching for the history of pizza on Google usually points to Lombardi's as the first. I would be interested in more information on the history of pizza in Gary as I am sure would many other folks.

Dave
NebGuy
Double Cheeseburger
RE: Gary, Indiana was first with Pizza 2006/11/11 11:33:55
You could get pizza in Omaha in 1946.
roossy90
Sirloin
RE: Gary, Indiana was first with Pizza 2006/11/11 12:55:43
Pizza History

Basic pizza most likely began in prehistoric times, with bread cooked on flat, hot stones.

Roughly 1,000 years ago herb-and-spice-covered circles of baked dough grew exceptionally popular in Naples, Italy. Known as focaccia, these rounds were served as an appetizer or a snack. (Source: Smithsonian)

Pizza developed in Italy in pre-refrigerator times. After focaccia, its most direct ancestor was "Casa de nanza," which means "take out before." Housewives would pound out dough into a thin crust and place leftovers on to bake. Pizza was a peasant food designed to be eaten without utensils and, like the French crepe and the Mexican taco, was a way to make use of fresh produce available locally and to get rid of leftovers.

But pizza as we know it could not have evolved until the late 1600s when Old World Europeans overcame their fear of a New World discovery - tomatoes. Native to Peru and Ecuador, a plant which produced yellow or red fruit (later called tomatoes) was introduced to Europe in the early 1500s. Brought back by Conquistadors to Spain, the tomato was thought to be poisonous and was viewed with suspicion. It wasn't until the late 1600s that Europeans began to eat the tomato. (Source: Smithsonian and PIZZA TODAY)

The peasants of Naples, Italy, who lived mostly off of bread and little else, were the first to add tomatoes to their focaccia bread rounds.

In 1830 pizza truly began with the opening of the world's first pizzeria. Named Port'Alba, the pizzas were cooked in an oven lined with lava from Mount Vesuvius, a volcano located on the Bay of Naples. (Source: Smithsonian)

Modern pizza was born in 1889 when Queen Margherita Teresa Giovanni, the consort of Umberto I, king of Italy, visited Naples. Don Raffaele Esposito, who owned a tavern-like place called Pietro Il Pizzaiolo, was asked to prepare a special dish in honor of the Queen's visit. Esposito developed a pizza featuring tomatoes, mozzarella cheese (a never before used ingredient made from the milk of water buffalo) and basil - ingredients bearing the colors red, white and green for the Italian flag. He named it the Margherita Pizza, after the guest of honor. Thus, the modern-day tomato-and-cheese pizza was born. (Source: Smithsonian and PIZZA TODAY)

Shops in the volcano-devastated city of Pompeii bear the characteristics of a pizzeria.

Marie Antionette's sister, Marie Carolina, wife of Ferdinand I of Sicily and Naples, had ovens built in the forest so she could enjoy pizza while the Royal Hunting Party feasted on wild ducklings and pigs killed in the hunt.

The popularity of pizza exploded throughout the country when World War II servicemen returning from Italy began opening pizzerias and raving about that "great Italian dish."

***In 1905, Gennaro Lombardi opened the first licensed American pizzeria, Lombardi's Pizzeria Napoletana, at 53-1/2 Spring Street in New York City. (From The Art of Pizzaiolo, by John Thorn.)

America is the new pizza renaissance leader in the world and is exporting our technology of pizza production and promotion on an ever-increasing basis.

Pizza restaurants are opening in such unlikely locations as the Caribbean islands of Curacao and Bonaire; the South Pacific atoll of Palau; and in most Arab countries. The deep-dish pizza was invented in Chicago by pizza entrepreneur Ike Sewell. His restaurant, Pizzeria Uno, is still going strong today.
**
Unless otherwise noted, all facts were supplied by PIZZA TODAY Magazine and the National Association of Pizza Operators (NAPO) which are also displayed on their web site at www.pizzatoday.com.
PapaJoe8
Sirloin
RE: Gary, Indiana was first with Pizza 2006/11/11 13:13:36
Now we know. Nice post Roossy!
Joe
Michael Hoffman
Double-chop Porterhouse
RE: Gary, Indiana was first with Pizza 2006/11/11 13:20:33
quote:
Originally posted by Polish guy

Gary, Indiana was the first or second in the U.S.A. to make and sell, Pizza. It was great. Do any of you remember this? Tell me of your eating Pizza in Gary, Indiana, in the 40's and 50's, for the old timers.

I believe I told you once before that the first pizza sold in the United States was sold by Gennaro Lombardi in New York in 1905, and that Frank Pepe opened his pizzeria in New Haven in 1925.

Oops! I see the Rooss got there ahead of me.
Jimeats
Filet Mignon
RE: Gary, Indiana was first with Pizza 2006/11/11 13:37:43
That must have been when they had the Statute of Liberty in Gary In. to welcome all those Italin immergrants to America. Chow Jim
UncleVic
Sirloin
RE: Gary, Indiana was first with Pizza 2006/11/11 14:27:11
All the above is good, but I heard Mexico was the first to start a pizza (tomato on bread with cheese). Sorry I cant quote my sources since It's been many a year since I heard this. Either way, whoever was first Cheers to them!!! Now if they could wander up into Michigan and show the shops around here how to make a decent one...
Michael Hoffman
Double-chop Porterhouse
RE: Gary, Indiana was first with Pizza 2006/11/11 17:11:26
Why UncleVic, I am surprised. After all, you have Domino's. And didn't Little Ceasar's get started there, as well?
PapaJoe8
Sirloin
RE: Gary, Indiana was first with Pizza 2006/11/11 17:28:10
Kind of off topic but Roossy's post brought up some questions.

Where did the Italians get those Water Buffalo? I hear they are gentle and like members of the family in Italy.

When, and why, and how did tomatoes turn red?
Joe
Michael Hoffman
Double-chop Porterhouse
RE: Gary, Indiana was first with Pizza 2006/11/11 19:11:54
quote:
Originally posted by PapaJoe8

Kind of off topic but Roossy's post brought up some questions.

Where did the Italians get those Water Buffalo? I hear they are gentle and like members of the family in Italy.

When, and why, and how did tomatoes turn red?
Joe

Ah, well, I'm glad you asked. Italians got those water buffalo the hard way. You see, first they had to get water.

One day, an Italian backpacker walking east to west through a gap in the Apennine Mountains ran out of land and dicovered a sea. After checking carefully he was able to determine that the sea was filled with water. Astounded, he decided to go back to his village in central Italy to let people know that he had found this stuff called water.

Unfortunately, or fortunately, as it turned out, while crossing back through the Apennines a snowstorm caused him to lose his way. Being the sort of person who would never allow a simple blizzard to deter him from his goal, he fought his way on through the blinding storm that seriously hampered his vision and, lo and behold (as opposed to Po and behold, which is another valley), He found another sea, and it, too, turned out to be filled with water.

This was an astounding turn of events, because the people of Italy did not know that there was water anywhere near their seriously parched nation. The fact is, they'd never actually heard of water, and as they had grapes with which to make wine, they could not have cared less. This fact,of course, leads the astute person to wonder how the backpacking Italian would have known that the wet stuff he'd discovered was water. But that's another story.

When he tried to tell the people from his village that he had found water both to the west and to the east, he was vilified as not being a true beliver in dryness. In effect, the people of his village buffaloed him.

And that, of course, is how Italians ended up with water buffalo.

Your question about how tomatoes turned red is more difficult to answer. However, after a great deal of research I believe I have found the answer.

In 1627, November, I believe, An Italian maiden (yes there was one, but she was so embarrassed to still be a maiden at age 14 that she refused to give her name to the National Enquirer) decided to take her annual bath in the Tiber River.

Looking around and checking carefully to make certain that there were no prying eyes, she slipped into a field of green tomatoes next to the Tiber and proceeded to disrobe prior to entering the water. Everything was going well until she realized that she had left her Lava Soap on the bank.

The maiden, fully believing that she was alone, slipped from the river to retrieve her soap. As it turned out, however, the green tomatoes were paying attention, as green tomatoes are wont to do under certain circumstances.

The sudden appearance of the naked maiden did, unfortunately, cause one of the green tomato plants, a male plant, you understand, to experience a sudden state of distention, or turgidity, which so embarrassed this plant that it turned bright red.

The other tomato plants, seeing this effect, were mesmerized, and could not help but try to do the same.

So, the fact is, tomatoes turned red because of both embarrasment and penis envy.

I hope this has helped.
ann peeples
Sirloin
RE: Gary, Indiana was first with Pizza 2006/11/11 19:42:31
Wonderful history lesson,Mr.Hoffman
Michael Hoffman
Double-chop Porterhouse
RE: Gary, Indiana was first with Pizza 2006/11/11 19:43:08
Thank you.
Poverty Pete
Double Chili Cheeseburger
RE: Gary, Indiana was first with Pizza 2006/11/11 19:59:13
Mr. Hoffman, were I wearing a hat right now, I would tip it to you.
Greymo
Filet Mignon
RE: Gary, Indiana was first with Pizza 2006/11/11 20:04:58
I stand in complete awe of the master of words, and bull!!!!
UncleVic
Sirloin
RE: Gary, Indiana was first with Pizza 2006/11/11 21:11:44
quote:
Originally posted by Michael Hoffman

Why UncleVic, I am surprised. After all, you have Domino's. And didn't Little Ceasar's get started there, as well?

In the voice of the Soup Nazi, TEN years of junk pizza for you.
Big Sausage
Cheeseburger
RE: Gary, Indiana was first with Pizza 2006/11/11 22:07:01
I've eaten many of pizza and beef sandwich on the Broadway corridor but for the life of me I'm having one hell of a time remembering back to the sixty's as to any of the names of those establishments.. I do remember the food was better then any NY pizza I've ever tried, but it's just a matter of what you grew up with.
BuddyRoadhouse
Filet Mignon
RE: Gary, Indiana was first with Pizza 2006/11/12 01:32:53
Michael Hoffman has a whimsical side??? Who knew? Ya live, ya learn. Nice tales of a tall nature Mr. Hoffman.

Buddy
Jimeats
Filet Mignon
RE: Gary, Indiana was first with Pizza 2006/11/12 06:07:03
Only a fisherman could spin a tale like that. Chow Jim
PapaJoe8
Sirloin
RE: Gary, Indiana was first with Pizza 2006/11/12 09:14:00
The things you can learn here at roadfood! Thanks Michael.
Joe
Davydd
Sirloin
RE: Gary, Indiana was first with Pizza 2006/11/12 15:26:59
Michael is spot on with the facts. I have nothing to refute what he says. Sounds plausible and is much more interesting than any other explanation.

The statement that Gary, IN was the first or second may have some basis in fact for what may have started a trend with the returning WWII servicemen. There were earlier pizza restaurants but they probably did not make an impact on a national basis. I do remember as a tiny child my parents bringing home pizza and raving about the new treat in the early 50s. They offered me a piece and I turned my nose up at it. They smiled and turned away. That was unusual. I usually had to eat what they wanted me to. It wasn't until much later that I understood.
Polish guy
Cheeseburger
RE: Gary, Indiana was first with Pizza 2006/11/15 12:34:52
Have any of you, old timers, ever had great Pizza in Gary, Indiana? If yes, where? When? What do you think?
Scorereader
Sirloin
RE: Gary, Indiana was first with Pizza 2006/11/15 14:37:59
I always though the tomato turned red because it saw the salad dressing.
Greymo
Filet Mignon
RE: Gary, Indiana was first with Pizza 2006/11/15 15:20:33
quote:
Originally posted by Scorereader

I always though the tomato turned red because it saw the salad dressing.



Not the old tomatoes that MH keeps around!
Big Sausage
Cheeseburger
RE: Gary, Indiana was first with Pizza 2006/11/15 15:21:41
Have any of you, old timers, ever had great Pizza in Gary, Indiana? If yes, where? When? What do you think?

I can't remember what I ate yesterday,and you want me to remember the name of the pizzeria in Gary where I ate in the 60's ? I frequented many of local bars and pizza joints in northwest Indiana back then but I'm at a loss as to the names of those establishments. One bar in particular was on the NE corner of Broadway and Ridge Rd.
roossy90
Sirloin
RE: Gary, Indiana was first with Pizza 2006/11/16 03:32:17
quote:
Originally posted by Big Sausage

I can't remember what I ate yesterday,and you want me to remember the name of the pizzeria in Gary where I ate in the 60's ?

desertdog
Double Chili Cheeseburger
RE: Gary, Indiana was first with Pizza 2006/11/16 09:37:30
I'm sure the first pizza in the US was made the day after the first Italian landed in the "new world."
Polish guy
Cheeseburger
RE: Gary, Indiana was first with Pizza 2006/11/16 10:37:30
That place in Gary, was in Glen Park, a part of Gary, and it was Zale's Tap, I think. Does that ring a bell. If it was, that was a place ownered by the brother of the great Tony Zale, the man of steel. One of the best prize fighters of the past.
Polish guy
Cheeseburger
RE: Gary, Indiana was first with Pizza 2006/11/16 10:43:18
The best was at a place on West 5th. Ave. downtown, just west of Washington St. on the north side of the street, just off the alley, a place called FLAMINGO PIZZA. This was great pizza, like none today.
Polish guy
Cheeseburger
RE: Gary, Indiana was first with Pizza 2006/11/20 09:57:33
Big Sausage,

Does any of this ring a bell? Coud this be the place you remember?
Sonny Funzio
Double Cheeseburger
RE: Gary, Indiana was first with Pizza 2006/11/20 11:39:52
Here's an interesting article on Gennaro Lombardi and Lombardi's Pizzeria from the archives of "Pizza Today"
http://www.pizzatoday.com/features_articles.shtml?article=MzMxNXN1cGVyMzMxMnNlY3JldDMzMTk=

Polish guy
Cheeseburger
RE: Gary, Indiana was first with Pizza 2006/11/21 08:45:54
Big Sausage;

Coud this be the place, Zale's Tap? Does it ring a bell?
Polish guy
Cheeseburger
RE: Gary, Indiana was first with Pizza 2006/11/23 09:52:32
After all the information you all gave me, I guess, Gary, Indiana, was not first but second with Pizza, but they did make the best, and now it is gone, never to be known by the young ones, but that's life.

You must be old to remember the good old days, and for our children and grandchildren, this time, will be the good old days for them someday.
mr chips
Filet Mignon
RE: Gary, Indiana was first with Pizza 2006/11/23 10:48:23
Gary, Indiana's most important contribution to world culture was probably the Jackson family.
Mosca
Filet Mignon
RE: Gary, Indiana was first with Pizza 2006/11/23 11:10:11
I dunno Polish Guy. My take on this is that if it were the case (Gary IN figuring prominently in US pizza history) then it would have shown up sooner and more prominently than on an obscure food-related internet forum in 2006. I seriously doubt that Gary was any more prominent in the pizza diaspora than any number of similar cities and towns. New Haven. Ithaca. Old Forge. Pittsburgh. Philadelphia. Chicago. There might be good pizza in Gary, but if you are going to make bold claims for Gary's primacy and importance I'd like to see some research and some rigor before I dismiss this as so much bombast and blather and braggadocio.


Tom
Big Sausage
Cheeseburger
RE: Gary, Indiana was first with Pizza 2006/11/23 11:56:03
Big Sausage;

Could this be the place, Zale's Tap? Does it ring a bell?

The name does not ring that bell, but if Zales was on the corner of Ridge and Broadway it might have been. I just remember some of the greatest sandwiches ever being made there along with a Stine of cold beer. Having driven that area a couple of years ago on a return visit home wanted to make me cry. How in the hell is that type of blight allowed to happen. SAD !
Jimeats
Filet Mignon
RE: Gary, Indiana was first with Pizza 2006/11/23 13:35:49
Braggadocio,What a great word, I'll have to remember it. Chow Jim
Michael Hoffman
Double-chop Porterhouse
RE: Gary, Indiana was first with Pizza 2006/11/23 14:18:28
The way I figure it, if Gary, Indiana didn't have it till the 1940s -- heck, even the '30s-- then it's not even close to being second, third, fourth, fifth or 25th.
Mosca
Filet Mignon
RE: Gary, Indiana was first with Pizza 2006/11/23 22:36:57
quote:
Originally posted by Jimeats

Braggadocio,What a great word, I'll have to remember it. Chow Jim


Yeah, but I think the OP is doing some tongue chewing (in cheek). But still 'n all.

Tom
Polish guy
Cheeseburger
RE: Gary, Indiana was first with Pizza 2006/11/24 18:19:57
First in the Midwest, anyway N.Y. does not know how to make Pizza.

Gary's was the best, does anyone remember this great Pizza?
Jimeats
Filet Mignon
RE: Gary, Indiana was first with Pizza 2006/11/25 07:47:13
I hate the taste of raw tounge, but I seem to be getting use to it.
Chow Jim
pastagirl
Junior Burger
RE: Gary, Indiana was first with Pizza 2006/11/25 18:21:48
Originally posted by Polish guy

First in the Midwest, anyway N.Y. does not know how to make Pizza.

Gary's was the best, does anyone remember this great Pizza?
[/qute]

THe best pizza was made by my mother in our kitchen, not sure if it was the first in the country. Her family came here in the 30's. Besides making the traditional baked pizza, a favorite in our house was fried pizza, not the sweet variety, but savory. a 6" round of dough fried on both sides, then topped with marinara sauce, lots of fresh basil and freshly grated cheese, no mozzarella! maybe an anchovy for my dad. She also fried calzones, never baked, this is how it was made in her area of Italy, no complaints from anyone either:)
Luisa
Michael Hoffman
Double-chop Porterhouse
RE: Gary, Indiana was first with Pizza 2006/11/25 18:27:15
I've had the fried pies and they were wonderful. You're right -- no mozzarella, just grated parmesan or pecorino.
pastagirl
Junior Burger
RE: Gary, Indiana was first with Pizza 2006/11/25 20:27:18
quote:
Originally posted by Michael Hoffman

I've had the fried pies and they were wonderful. You're right -- no mozzarella, just grated parmesan or pecorino.


May I ask where you had them? I've never had the fried pizza at a restaurant, but some of the pizzerias in my area do make fried calzones. Mom said they were very popular in Naples, along with panzarotti (fried potato croquettes), she also said the thieves in Naples were so good, they'd steal the pierced earrings off of women:)

Thanks
Luisa
Michael Hoffman
Double-chop Porterhouse
RE: Gary, Indiana was first with Pizza 2006/11/25 20:44:38
quote:
Originally posted by pastagirl

quote:
Originally posted by Michael Hoffman

I've had the fried pies and they were wonderful. You're right -- no mozzarella, just grated parmesan or pecorino.


May I ask where you had them? I've never had the fried pizza at a restaurant, but some of the pizzerias in my area do make fried calzones. Mom said they were very popular in Naples, along with panzarotti (fried potato croquettes), she also said the thieves in Naples were so good, they'd steal the pierced earrings off of women:)

Thanks
Luisa

I had them in the homes of relatives and friends in New Haven, Connecticut.
chrasimp
Junior Burger
RE: Gary, Indiana was first with Pizza 2006/11/26 01:17:41
I just want to clear a few things up for you guys. Flamingo Pizza was Officially established in 1941 as one of the regions first Pizza Places. Despite the economic hardships that plagued the area Flamingos is still Open and serving the original hand tossed "region style" pizza. Though they have moved to the east side, it is one of the longest operating businesses in Gary, next to Peerless Potato chips and the Mills. I'm not sure how much you remember from the original menu but the ground sausage, sauce, cheese, dough and preperation have all remained the same over the years. They also serve the original beef sandwiches and wonderful house dressing. Though many of the prices reflect the change in times they sill have a mug of beer for a buck.
Polish guy
Cheeseburger
RE: Gary, Indiana was first with Pizza 2006/11/26 12:52:44
Where are they now, I lost contact with any of their places left?

Last I heard there was one in Miller, but not sure where it is, can you help?

The one in Glen Park, closed a few years ago, and the one downtown closed many years ago.

I live in Valparaiso, Indiana, and would go, if I knew where it was.
Is it only carry out, or do they have dine in also?

Polish guy
Cheeseburger
RE: Gary, Indiana was first with Pizza 2006/11/27 15:01:45
chrasimp,

How is that you know of Flamingo Pizza? Are you from this area?
Where, and are you still there, or when did you leave? Are you old enough to remember the great Flamingo Pizza, when Gus was around?
STARTRADER
Junior Burger
RE: Gary, Indiana was first with Pizza 2006/11/27 15:49:49
During the year of 1905, Lombardi's of New York City was licensed by the City of New York, becoming America's First Pizzeria. In addition there are many East Coast pizzerias that are almost as old and still operating.


ZekeTheCat
Cheeseburger
RE: Gary, Indiana was first with Pizza 2006/11/28 10:54:03
Apparently Flamingo Pizza is still in business - I doubt if it is the same as the 5th ave location of the 1950's. My family lived in Brunswick (far west side)for 30 years - and used to get pizza a lot there at Flamingo on 5th ave - great flavor. It was featured in Colliers Magazine , March 7, 1953 in article about pizza.

Flamingo Pizza of Miller , 8341 Locust Ave , Gary , In 46403

Yahoo Map:
http://maps.yahoo.com/#gid1=15969151&q1=8341%20locust%20ave,%20gary,%20in&trf=0&mvt=m&lon=-87.237775&lat=41.618073&mag=3
chrasimp
Junior Burger
RE: Gary, Indiana was first with Pizza 2006/11/28 17:22:14
I Have been working at flamingo for a few years. It is right across the street from Beach Cafe (famous for Lake Perch) on the corner of Shelby and Locust. The original recepie along with the original oven, dough mixer, stetcher and grinder are all still used. I Shipped 10 frozen pizzas on dry-ice to a couple in WI for their 50th wedding anniversery. They had first met there 52 years ago. They sent a thank you letter which stated "despite the different atmosphere we would like to express our deepest appreciation for allowing us to reminise over pizza that like our relationship still uphold the quality of yesteryear." I am not old enough to remember the original but those who our claim nothing has changed except the prices. If you get a chance check it out. I would suggest eating there if everyone in your party is over 21 because 35-40 minutes in a box doesn't do it must justice. Let me know what you think.
Polish guy
Cheeseburger
RE: Gary, Indiana was first with Pizza 2006/11/28 20:47:31
Thank you for the information, we will be stopping by. I hope it is as good as once was.
Polish guy
Cheeseburger
RE: Gary, Indiana was first with Pizza 2006/11/29 12:09:33
One more questions, I have been told, that this area, Miller, is a high crime area, would we be safe to go there?
Scorereader
Sirloin
RE: Gary, Indiana was first with Pizza 2006/11/29 16:19:54
quote:
Originally posted by pastagirl

quote:
Originally posted by Michael Hoffman

I've had the fried pies and they were wonderful. You're right -- no mozzarella, just grated parmesan or pecorino.


May I ask where you had them? I've never had the fried pizza at a restaurant, but some of the pizzerias in my area do make fried calzones. Mom said they were very popular in Naples, along with panzarotti (fried potato croquettes), she also said the thieves in Naples were so good, they'd steal the pierced earrings off of women:)

Thanks
Luisa


they roll and fry pizzas at a place called Josie's in Potsdam, NY. They call 'em pizza rolls - go figure. But these have mozzarella. They've been a Potsdam tradition for a couple decades now.
Polish guy
Cheeseburger
RE: Gary, Indiana was first with Pizza 2006/12/01 10:54:20
Is this place safe, and have parking?
Polish guy
Cheeseburger
RE: Gary, Indiana was first with Pizza 2006/12/02 12:22:55
Some guy just listed Pizza history but did not even add Gary. Shows what does he know. Also, Gary, Indiana, had the best Pizza ever, and New York does not know Pizza.
STARTRADER
Junior Burger
RE: Gary, Indiana was first with Pizza 2006/12/02 14:15:08
Check out this site for the history of Pizza going back to the 6th century B.C. http://www.nypizzapie.com/pizzahistory

Then go to restuarants on roadfood and search for pizza in all states. With very few exceptions, they are all located in New York and Connecticut. None are located in Indiana (what a surprise!) I have tried 11 of the 38 listed and the reviews are accurate. I grew up in Brooklyn, live in New Jersey for the past 33 years, and have traveled all over the country and can assure you that the best Pizza is made in the north east.
pastagirl
Junior Burger
RE: Gary, Indiana was first with Pizza 2006/12/02 18:41:03
[
they roll and fry pizzas at a place called Josie's in Potsdam, NY. They call 'em pizza rolls - go figure. But these have mozzarella. They've been a Potsdam tradition for a couple decades now.



What area of NY is that?
are they rolled up like a jelly roll, then fried, is so that sounds SO SO good. I going to make fried pizzas tomorrow, anyone in the area is welcome to stop in.
Luisa
Page: 12 > Showing page 1 of 2