I have enjoyed Grauter's, the Cincinnati-based mini-chain for years. I don't know if they reach up into your part of Ohio, but if they do they are worth a try. I like the Toffee Chip myself, but the Black Raspberry Chip i supposed to be their flagship flavor.
On the less expensive side, the Convenience store chain in Ohio..Rural Farmers Dairy Stores or some name like that puts out a very good ice cream at a buck a scoop for big cones. We look for those stores whenever we head for the Mt Vernon area for Genealogy research!!