I'm really confused about the process, and indeed the entire purpose of reviews here...
I say this because after submitting a review for a place I recently tried, I got an email saying that I didn't rate it high enough...and also didn't include the average price...
I tried to write a review about a place and I got an email from Bruce Blimes that said, in part: Hi John, thank you for submitting Be-Bop's Diner to Roadfood.com. Before we can consider your submission for publication on the website, you'll need to make the following changes or additions:
• You gave the restaurant a relatively low rating. We aim to post only the best of the best at Roadfood.com.
• The Average Price field must be entered.
And my REPLY: Howdy...
I don't know their "average price"...all I know is what I paid for the meal I ate...
I'm not sure how my rating scale jives with others...I thought it was a
fairly good and reasonable rating for my 1st time there, and it would be totally dishonest
to give it the top rave review rating unless I felt it was just absolutrely spectacular...
For me ,it's a GOOD average place...and the bottom line is that I *will*
go back again...I'd rate it around 7 on a scale of 10...
Perhaps y'all might want to rethink your rating system...if you allow ONLY
the best of the best (as you say) then that is a
skewed result and perhaps not an ACCURATE
reflection of the experience...You're creating an artificial sense that everything
posted is fabulous, when in reality we know that medium ratings are certainly no insult...
What IS the point of having multiple choice ratings if you summerily dismiss all but the top ones...??? IMHO that is just plain goofey...the object of a REAL review is an honest evaluation, not one articifially peppered with nothing but superlatives that might not be warranted...
Can you dig it...???
*************************************************************************
While I can see the value of not posting crappy reviews, this very heavy FILTERING of reviews by the Roadfood.com staff, et al, is by process eliminating some potentially nice places to eat that may have gottem medium reviews...
Don't you want honest reviews so folks can make up their own minds...or is the intent to provides a "call to action" for only a select few restaurants (which equals free promotion)...???
Here is what I wrote about the place I attempted to review...and let the readers make up thir own mind(s) as they see fit...
http://www.roadfood.com/Forums/fb.ashx?m=677495 ******************************************************************************