philly cheesesteaks in nyc

Post
bubbaboy
Junior Burger
2003/12/09 13:06:40
carl's steaks has opened on 34th and third avenue and i can now say the nyc finally has a place where people can get a real philly cheesesteak...during the last month i've eaten at least 20...i apologize if this topic has already been covered.

JD
CheeseWit
Double Chili Cheeseburger
RE: philly cheesesteaks in nyc 2003/12/09 13:15:26
That's ok...you can post this on the best cheesesteak thread. You're the third or fourth person that has been high on Carl's. I have to try it sometime.
bubbaboy
Junior Burger
RE: philly cheesesteaks in nyc 2003/12/09 13:23:51
thanks for being kind...i don't post much but i felt i had to say something about carl's...it just that we've had nothing in nyc for so long...i might be over hyping it.
signman
Double Chili Cheeseburger
RE: philly cheesesteaks in nyc 2003/12/10 00:49:12
Bubbaboy,

Does Carl chop his steak into little bits?
bubbaboy
Junior Burger
RE: philly cheesesteaks in nyc 2003/12/10 09:33:03
yes
Spudnut
Double Cheeseburger
RE: philly cheesesteaks in nyc 2003/12/10 10:34:31
I also like Carl's. The style is modeled on Jim's, more or less, so if you don't like Jim's this one might not be for you. I happen to like the steak chopped.

Bubbaboy, you've eaten 20 in a month? Thank goodness for the NYC smoking ban, because I wouldn't want anyone to light a match around you!
bubbaboy
Junior Burger
RE: philly cheesesteaks in nyc 2003/12/10 10:44:50
yeah things have not been so fresh in that area lately...it's just one of those things...i've been without them for so long i'm kind of psycho over them.
bubbaboy
Junior Burger
RE: philly cheesesteaks in nyc 2003/12/10 11:24:33
clothier...LOL...that's great
CheeseWit
Double Chili Cheeseburger
RE: philly cheesesteaks in nyc 2003/12/10 11:40:18
...the story of my life. Forget Jared. Be like me and eat.
quote:
Originally posted by clothier

quote:
Originally posted by Phil J.

I also like Carl's. The style is modeled on Jim's, more or less, so if you don't like Jim's this one might not be for you. I happen to like the steak chopped.

Bubbaboy, you've eaten 20 in a month? Thank goodness for the NYC smoking ban, because I wouldn't want anyone to light a match around you!


Maybe they could turn you into Jared's evil twin:

"I eat here everyday, and I've gained 10 lbs in a month."
MOC
Junior Burger
RE: philly cheesesteaks in nyc 2003/12/26 20:01:37
Have you tried the Philly Cheese Steak at Fetch? 3rd Ave and 94th - it's very good, but the surroundings a little too nice! I'll have to try Carl's they use CheeseWhiz right? Otherwise it doesn't count as real
bubbaboy
Junior Burger
RE: philly cheesesteaks in nyc 2004/01/05 16:14:10
thanks moc i live up there i'll try it