I'll be the third one to recommend the Fish House in Key Largo, and to get the yellowtail snapper Matecumbe style. Matecumbe is an American Indian word. I have no idea what it means, but part of Islamorda is on Upper Matecumbe Key, about 20 miles "south" of the Fish House.
In Islamorada is the Islamorda Fish Company, which was pretty good. It is now a chain restaurant associated with Bass Pro shops or Outdoor World (one of those type places). But, the one in Islamorada is the original, and is a little different and better than the chain outlets. I wouldn't pick it over the Fish House, but if you're in the upper keys for a while, and want more choices, you can add that one.
post edited by Glenn1234 - 2012/01/16 02:06:45