The Best Fish & Chips

RE: The Best Fish & Chips (rokelemaster)

Fri, 04 Sep 2009 19:09:57 GMT

I loved Arthur Treacher's.. That where I learned about malt vinegar on F&C's (we didn't know about such things here in WV!) I really liked the 'chips'. That my favorite form of french fries!

RE: The Best Fish & Chips (BuddyRoadhouse)

Fri, 04 Sep 2009 17:44:32 GMT

JBarry713

(McDonough's in Galway, Ireland is still tops - at least for the fish).

Thanks to the wonder of Google Map's Streetview function, those who have not been fortunate enough to visit the Auld Sod can now at least see McDonagh's (don't feel bad about the misspelling, I got also it wrong in an earlier post in this thread). There are also numerous shots of the interior, and multiple reviews. Sorry, no shots of the food.

Buddy

RE: The Best Fish & Chips (Mike_NZ)

Fri, 04 Sep 2009 04:34:05 GMT

Personally,
I prefer the fish and chips out of the paper.
As tm199(?) above alluded to, fish and chips are very in-expensive down here in New Zealand.
I've just had a feed of them, man am I full!
Cost me all of NZ$9.00.

RE: The Best Fish & Chips (MissJohnnycakes)

Tue, 30 Sep 2008 19:12:17 GMT

The Bayside Restaurant, near the town beach and the Audubon preserve in Westport, MA, has the best fish and chips I've tasted. They use cod, or at least they used to.

They also have some unusual items such as a delicious homemade Indian pudding.

RE: The Best Fish & Chips (JBarry713)

Mon, 11 Feb 2008 17:03:23 GMT

quote:
Originally posted by malheureux

My favorite for Fish 'N' Chips is Ye Olde English in Woonsocket, RI. I've yet to find any other like it anywhere in the USA. Well worth the trip if you are ever in the Boston-Worcester-Providence triangle. I was born and raised in Wonnsocket and in the 1950s and '60s there were any number of fish 'n' chip shops around the city to satisfy Catholics on meatless Fridays. Sad to say, but these little shops are all but gone. Ye Olde English remains. Every time I visit home, I get my fix. Currently, I live in OR but have yet to taste anything as satisfy as Olde English!

Thanks for the tip. I was visiting a friend in Woonsocket on Saturday and realized that he lived right down the street from Ye Olde English on South Main. It might have been the best fish and chips I've had in the US along with Westfair Fish & Chips in Westport, CT (McDonough's in Galway, Ireland is still tops - at least for the fish). The fish was great - tender, flaky with a good crispy crust. The tater sauce was excellent (and I believe homemade)and the chips were very meaty and pretty crispy, though not as crispy as they should be, especially the ones that were sitting underneath the fish. Still I really enjoyed these chips, this being said despite the fact that I am not a big fan of chips/french fries in general. Also, the staff was very friendly, helpful, and quick with their service even though they were closing right after I walked in the door. Highly recommended if you are in the area.

RE: The Best Fish & Chips (kozel)

Fri, 03 Aug 2007 08:48:00 GMT

quote:
Originally posted by Stewdude

Assault and Battery in Greenwich Village New York makes a very authentic,very good Fish & Chips, along with mushy peas. And you get to finish off with a deep fried Mars Bar.

Also posted by billyboy, this place was just featured on Bobby Flay's show Throwdown and thankfully Flay lost. It's on my list to try.

http://www.asaltandbattery.com/

RE: The Best Fish & Chips (Miss Cotton Candy)

Wed, 11 Jul 2007 01:17:07 GMT

Odd request from a noob but ... anyone ever just try to make and fry the batter from F&C Mixes?

I am obsessed with the little batter crumbs, or cracklin' as they say in the resturants, that are scattered about on my plate when I go to the chain places like LJS of Captain D's, I often request an extra carton of them on the side. Far better than potato chips and so daggum sinfully good too. I'd be forever grateful if anyone could give me such a recipe for a delicious batter to fry and crumb up!

Oh, as for a good place - I often go to this kiosk when festival time comes about in my city. They makes some delicous F&C and even have dessert like batter dipped Snickers, which I have yet to try.

RE: The Best Fish & Chips (tiki)

Thu, 28 Jun 2007 21:38:19 GMT

quote:
Originally posted by Sundancer7

quote:
Originally posted by tiki

Lets see,--it was the "Summer of Love"--San Francisco--we were all flat broke most of the time--didn't
have a kitchen--heck 'we didn-t have a house to put it in --but if you could panhandle a buck--or ontimidate some tourist to pay you for taking your picture--there was a fish and chips place right near the end of the street--about a block and a half from the entrance to Golden Gate Park that was wonderful!!--and that buck would get you na big old newspaper cone full of greay potatos and two gig hunks of fish! Have no idea what the name of the place was---and it probably wasnt the best fish and chips in the world--but it kept a lot hippies alive.---and i liked it!!

Tiki, have you recovered yet?

Sounds like you enjoyed your days of being a hippie. Now you are an old hippie

Paul E. Smith
Knoxville, TN

Loved every minute of it---as a matter of fact i have started on a book---kind of the hippie version of "On the Road"--its called--"Whose Movie Is This Anyway?"

RE: The Best Fish & Chips (Twinwillow)

Thu, 28 Jun 2007 13:26:29 GMT

It's possible I have posted my response to this topic on one of the previous pages.
The very best fish and chips I have ever had was at, "Sea Fare" in the Pimlico section of London near Victoria Station. If you are in London, just ask your cab driver. Chances are, judging by the many cabs, double and triple parked outside, he's probably a frequent diner there himself.
They use very fresh fish fried in peanut oil. The oil is changed very often so the fish has a fresh and clean taste.
And, it's a large airy space with comfortable seating-unlike most "chippies".

RE: The Best Fish & Chips (cd348)

Thu, 28 Jun 2007 13:04:47 GMT

The best that I had was at a little fish and chips stand outside of the NCO club at Alconbury AB in England. It was outstanding. Wrapped in newspaper and sprinkled with malt vinegar, it was absolutely outstanding. I had some in London too. They were all good but not as good as the one on Alconbury.

RE: The Best Fish & Chips (Sundancer7)

Thu, 28 Jun 2007 12:40:35 GMT

quote:
Originally posted by tiki

Lets see,--it was the "Summer of Love"--San Francisco--we were all flat broke most of the time--didn't
have a kitchen--heck 'we didn-t have a house to put it in --but if you could panhandle a buck--or ontimidate some tourist to pay you for taking your picture--there was a fish and chips place right near the end of the street--about a block and a half from the entrance to Golden Gate Park that was wonderful!!--and that buck would get you na big old newspaper cone full of greay potatos and two gig hunks of fish! Have no idea what the name of the place was---and it probably wasnt the best fish and chips in the world--but it kept a lot hippies alive.---and i liked it!!

Tiki, have you recovered yet?

Sounds like you enjoyed your days of being a hippie. Now you are an old hippie

Paul E. Smith
Knoxville, TN

RE: The Best Fish & Chips (tiki)

Thu, 28 Jun 2007 11:49:01 GMT

Lets see,--it was the "Summer of Love"--San Francisco--we were all flat broke most of the time--didn't
have a kitchen--heck 'we didn-t have a house to put it in --but if you could panhandle a buck--or ontimidate some tourist to pay you for taking your picture--there was a fish and chips place right near the end of the street--about a block and a half from the entrance to Golden Gate Park that was wonderful!!--and that buck would get you na big old newspaper cone full of greay potatos and two gig hunks of fish! Have no idea what the name of the place was---and it probably wasnt the best fish and chips in the world--but it kept a lot hippies alive.---and i liked it!!

RE: The Best Fish & Chips (rainroosty)

Thu, 28 Jun 2007 09:40:06 GMT

Arthur Treacher's is excellent here in Lake Worth (South Florida). It is located in a "Miami Subs Grill", along with Nathan's & Kenny Rogers....it's PERFECT every time! (No kidding!)
(my first post on Roadfood) :-)

RE: The Best Fish & Chips (KOK)

Thu, 24 May 2007 11:14:27 GMT

I'll second Eamonn's in Alexandria, Va. Cathal Armstrong (of Restaurant Eve fame) is from Ireland and this chipper has some excellent fish and excellent chips. People rave about the skate but I've only had the cod.

AND they have deep fried Snickers bars (and other candy too).

Thanks,

Kevin

RE: The Best Fish & Chips (hatteras04)

Thu, 24 May 2007 10:53:03 GMT

I tried Wendell's Pub in Westerville, OH near Columbus a few months ago and the fish and chips were the highlight of the menu. But the real story about Wendell's is ther national recognition for being the Number 1 place to go Number 2.

http://www.bestrestroom.com/rest_winner06.html

RE: The Best Fish & Chips (zrrifle)

Thu, 24 May 2007 10:45:16 GMT

Dubliner's far from having the best F&C in DC. More like mediocre. Elephant & Castle, the English pub/restaurant off Penn is a bit better, though not your traditional F&C plate. The best places I tried are actually both in Alexandria. One is a place called Eamon's, which is pretty authentic: http://www.eamonnsdublinchipper.com/ , but the best I've tried, in my opinion, is at Theismann's: http://www.joetheismanns.com/main.html

But it's a matter of taste/opinion I suppose.

RE: The Best Fish & Chips (billyboy)

Mon, 16 Apr 2007 14:50:35 GMT

Love A Salt & Battery in the West Village, NYC. They've got great cod and haddock. The chips are just greasy enough and very tasty doused with some malt vinegar and piled on a buttered roll to make my own "chip butty". For some reason though, I'm addicted to their deep fried chicken chunks. They're crispy, greasy, and have a slight curry taste to them that really elevates them beyond any chicken tender I've ever had.

RE: The Best Fish & Chips (Scorereader)

Mon, 16 Apr 2007 01:10:26 GMT

I hit The Dubliner, an Irish restaurant near Union Station in DC, after the Cherry Blossom Parade for a couple Irish Car Bombs and Fish and Chips. Both were excellent! didn't bring my camera, so no pics. But it may be the best Fish and Chips in DC.
Corned beef sandwich, cream of potato soup and shepherd's pie were all smashing successes as well at our table.

RE: The Best Fish & Chips (big g in joisey)

Wed, 04 Apr 2007 21:22:06 GMT

Well the secret is out,I took ScreenBear's advice and tried the fish n chips at Top's diner in East Newark and it was a great meal. I've lived in Kearny for most of my life and have been to Top's quite a few times,but never had the fish n chips,due to the fact that the Argyle and The Thistle were always a staple of the area for so many years,but the meal at Tops diner included soup,salad,coleslaw and the fish and chips,and believe me the quality of the meal is just as good or maybe even a little better.Thanks again for the tip.

RE: The Best Fish & Chips (schtib)

Thu, 29 Mar 2007 17:27:17 GMT

Anyone in the Fort Worth, TX area know of ANY good fish and chip joints besides Zeke's? Any good seafood restaurant recommendations would be great as well. I live in the Keller/Alliance area and don't know of any good places!

Thanks,

Mario

RE: The Best Fish & Chips (dianl1442)

Fri, 05 Jan 2007 15:14:28 GMT

I have to agree with Spadoman. Mac's Fish and Chips on Larpenteur Ave in St Paul Minnesota does a great job with their Halibut and Chips. Their Chips get soggy if you try to do take out, ok if you eat in. The Halibut is great.

RE: The Best Fish & Chips (Squidly)

Thu, 02 Nov 2006 22:57:50 GMT

The chip shop in Dunoon, Scotland at Holy Loch. Only real fish and chips I've ever had. Hot fish and chips, coarse salt, and malt vinegar. Outstanding!

RE: The Best Fish & Chips (ScreenBear)

Sun, 08 Oct 2006 22:35:34 GMT

Fish 'n' Chips wise, the best kept secret in New Jersey is the Tops Diner, East Newark, New Jersey. It's a special and they only prepare it on Fridays.

What makes this accomplishment particularly interesting is that the Tops, which is a far better diner than any for many miles around, is in rather close proximity to Kearny, New Jersey, home of the revered Argyle and Thistle restaurants, each renowned for their fish 'n' chips.

Well, I'm not one to venture on sacrilege by saying the Tops's rendition of fish 'n' chips is better than Argyles's and Thistles's. But I heartily suggest you give it a try. Judge for yourself.

The special is a soup to nuts deal. Bring an appetite. If they have the blueberry cobbler the Friday you're there, make that your dessert choice as part of your meal. Boy, is it good!

One note, though. While the fish is excellent, and presented in a generous portion of two good-sized filets, the chips are French fries. They're good, but, at no extra charge, you can have the superior waffle fries instead. Good choice. You'll be back.

The Bear

RE: The Best Fish & Chips (cheesybellybutton)

Fri, 15 Sep 2006 10:38:02 GMT

quote:
Originally posted by twodales

Has anyone tried the Duke of Perth in Chicago? I've heard that the Fish & Chips are tasty but I've yet to try.

I had the fish & chips there years ago and they were good. Couldn't tell you what they're like now.

If any of you are in London again, I'd suggest you come to The Golden Hind (http://www.london-eating.co.uk/2412.htm). It's an authentic old "chippy" in a lovely area, and everything on the menu us great. Be sure to get some mushy peas (as it just isn't as good without!)

RE: The Best Fish & Chips (buffetbuster)

Fri, 15 Sep 2006 10:31:19 GMT

Another really good place for Fish & Chips is Baxter's in Hyannis, Mass. I just ate there for the first time a few weeks ago. I thought $15.95 was a lot to pay for an order, but once I tasted how good it was, I wasn't complaining. A cup of the chowder and sitting at a picnic table overlooking the water completed the memorable meal.

http://www.baxterscapecod.com/

RE: The Best Fish & Chips (Joisey)

Fri, 15 Sep 2006 09:39:32 GMT

BTW--there is an Irish fest tomorrow in Sea Girt NJ--they usually have either Argyle or Stuarts of kearny as a Fish N Chip vendor.

Can't wait!

RE: The Best Fish & Chips (GCD1962)

Thu, 14 Sep 2006 20:42:18 GMT

Fish & Chips one of favorites. Best I've had is at Skagway Fish Co restaurant in Skagway, Alaska. Kind of out of the way, but the deep fried fresh halibut is always cooked to perfection, the frys always fresh & hot, and downed with an Alaskan Amber beer, it's a combo that can't be beat. Long time ago, in Greenwich, Ct, The Clam Box had great fish & chips. I think they used haddock.

RE: The Best Fish & Chips (SassyGritsAL)

Fri, 01 Sep 2006 09:47:23 GMT

My gosh, that picture of fish and chips looks mouth-watering. The fish looks good and crispy and the fries look the way I like them. Whish I was in RI for lunch today; but guess I'll have Mickey D's! Just ain't the same is it?

RE: The Best Fish & Chips (big g in joisey)

Fri, 01 Sep 2006 00:20:58 GMT

My two favorites would have to be The Argyle & The Thistle both in
Kearny,NJ. When it's possible, it's great to enjoy the meal at either
restaurant,especially when they serve the fish right from the deep fryer,the outside crunchy and golden and the fish cooked just right, along with the fries and coleslaw a very satisfying meal.

RE: The Best Fish & Chips (malheureux)

Tue, 22 Aug 2006 20:32:18 GMT

My favorite for Fish 'N' Chips is Ye Olde English in Woonsocket, RI. I've yet to find any other like it anywhere in the USA. Well worth the trip if you are ever in the Boston-Worcester-Providence triangle. I was born and raised in Wonnsocket and in the 1950s and '60s there were any number of fish 'n' chip shops around the city to satisfy Catholics on meatless Fridays. Sad to say, but these little shops are all but gone. Ye Olde English remains. Every time I visit home, I get my fix. Currently, I live in OR but have yet to taste anything as satisfy as Olde English!