Hydrox cookies back - limited time

RE: Hydrox cookies back - limited time (Diner-Lover)

Wed, 08 Oct 2008 18:29:03 GMT

That is funny, Sweetslover! It's inspiring me to do a side-by-side taste comparison.... Off to the supermarket!

RE: Hydrox cookies back - limited time (sweetslover)

Mon, 06 Oct 2008 23:33:41 GMT

Well, I have another 'Hydrox' story to share.

I packed some Hydrox in my 13 year-old DD's school lunch today. Guess what? "Mom, I like those cookies you packed in my lunch today BETTER than Oreos. I shared them with two other friends and they loved them too. They wanted to know what kind they were. Please don't buy Oreos anymore."

Isn't that too funny! They're not like I remember 'em, but my DD still notices a 'better' difference between Hydrox and Oreos. Long live Hydrox! (But, please, Keebler (or Sunshine)make them the way you used to.)

RE: Hydrox cookies back - limited time (lisamnorth)

Mon, 06 Oct 2008 19:08:47 GMT

supposedly French Chew Taffy is the same

The closest thing to Bonomo's Turkish taffy. Same taste, texture and shape - put it in the refrigerator and crack it. A nostalgic favorite since the 50's. Available in four flavors. Treat your children to a taste of your childhood today!

You can get it at hometownfavorites.com and here
http://www.oldtimecandy.com/french-chew.htm

RE: Hydrox cookies back - limited time (Diner-Lover)

Mon, 06 Oct 2008 18:38:35 GMT

I had no problem finishing them either, Sweetslover, since I love Oreos-- I was just really looking forward to reliving my childhood and hoping for that nostalgic Hydrox taste. Alas-- it was not meant to be.... I'll just have to keep my fingers crossed that Bonomos Turkish Taffy makes a return sometime in my lifetime!

RE: Hydrox cookies back - limited time (sweetslover)

Sun, 05 Oct 2008 00:04:28 GMT

Originally posted by Diner-Lover

Sweetslover, I'm sorry to say that your parents will be surprised only to find that Hydrox doesn't taste like the Hydrox we remember; they now taste like Oreos.
[/quote

Well, I found them (they 'jumped out' at me at Wal-Mart.) You're right, they taste like Oreos. (Maybe a tad less sweet, but not like the ones I remembered while growing up. I wanted them to taste like Oreos then, which is so funny!)

They're still good enough for our family to finish the package, but I'll just by Oreos next time.

RE: Hydrox cookies back - limited time (Diner-Lover)

Wed, 01 Oct 2008 08:17:59 GMT

Sweetslover, I'm sorry to say that your parents will be surprised only to find that Hydrox doesn't taste like the Hydrox we remember; they now taste like Oreos.

RE: Hydrox cookies back - limited time (sweetslover)

Tue, 30 Sep 2008 21:15:46 GMT

My parents always bought Hydrox, NEVER Oreos, for our school lunches. (I didn't like Hydrox, and was envious of my friends who had Oreos, because Oreos were sweeter.)

That said, I'm THRILLED to hear that Hydrox are available again, as I can't wait to surprise my 83 year-old parents (who were sad when they couldn't find them anymore.)

RE: Hydrox cookies back - limited time (joanie41)

Sun, 28 Sep 2008 11:51:04 GMT

Ellen, thanks for your kind offer. Still haven't seen them in our MD stores. Truthfully, I'd say there is an excellent chance that I'll taste them and be completely underwhelmed. But I do remember liking them better than Oreos way-back-when. I'll have to look for Famous Amos brand as well, since you said they taste the same.

I will send you an address separately...I'd probably have you mail them to the Columbia address, since getting packages here in the city is a pain. I've got to do a little shopping later today, so I'll do one last check, and if they aren't there, I'll take you up on the offer. Thanks again!!

PS Just found out I'll be moving to the Eastern Shore of MD (Easton area) and although it's not my beloved SoJersey shore, I'll once again be near the water...hate moving but looking forward to the change. Will miss Bmore, though!!

RE: Hydrox cookies back - limited time (pumppantry)

Sat, 27 Sep 2008 15:47:50 GMT

FYI for those in the Northeast- I own a grocery store in VT and our wholesaler (AG New England) just brought Hydrox in stock so look for them to be showing up in independent grocery stores in New England.
(our first case will arrive 10/1) Can't wait to try a sample. (Strictly for quality control purposes only, of course!)

RE: Hydrox cookies back - limited time (ann peeples)

Sat, 27 Sep 2008 15:18:06 GMT

Never had a Hydrox-barely ever had a store bought cookie growing up.My Mom was a June Cleaver type.Occasionally we had Oreos-okay for me...

RE: Hydrox cookies back - limited time (Diner-Lover)

Sat, 27 Sep 2008 14:12:44 GMT

When I was a kid, my Mom bought Hydrox because my Dad liked them. What I remember was a thinner, crispier cookie than Oreo, and the chocolate was deeper-flavored, sort of like the difference between milk and semisweet chocolate. Also, in the original Hydrox, the icing between the darker chocolate wafers was thinner than Oreo's, not as creamy.

I bought a package of Hydrox at my local ACME supermarket a couple of weeks ago and thought they tasted just like Oreos, so I was disappointed.

RE: Hydrox cookies back - limited time (Twinwillow)

Wed, 24 Sep 2008 20:16:54 GMT

If I were to eat a Hydrox cookie, and I did say, if. I would eat an Oreo. But, of course, not, just one. I defy anyone to eat just, one.

RE: Hydrox cookies back - limited time (uncledaveyo)

Wed, 24 Sep 2008 19:39:52 GMT

Personally never understood the attraction of chalky textured cocoa flavored cookies with shortening-like overly sweet filling. But hey, to each his own. I've heard whispers that some people even like catsup on a hotdog. Gasp!

RE: Hydrox cookies back - limited time (ellen4641)

Wed, 24 Sep 2008 19:26:36 GMT

quote:
Originally posted by DavidEMartin

The local Pick-N-Save has had Hydrox on sale

The chocolate flavor was subtler than Oreos, as befits a cookie aimed at an adult palette. The filling was smaller than an Oreo but that did not matter. It tasted better and did not have the disturbing after-feel of Oreo's white stuff.

Agreed! I just bought the renewed Hydrox cookiesa few weeks back, and I do like them better than Oreo's, too.
And you know what I do to compensate for the smaller Hydrox filling?!?
I often make my own "double stuff Hydrox" by taking off the tops/bottoms of them and combining them together!

Note the retro packaging...I'm not crazy about it; it's very subdued, and did'nt exactly jump out from the supermarket shelf at me. And it was stuck on the 2nd shelf from the bottom; somehow it got lousy product placement (it deserves better!)

I went wild and also bought the Famous Amos cookies, and ironically, they tasted VERY much like the Hydrox!
My hips felt huge for a few days afterwards, though!!

Who else likes dipping some of them in milk, too?!?
ellen
p.s. Hey, Joanie, if you still can't find the Hydrox in your Baltimore area, I can always send you a few packages. (for a $4.95 flat rate, I can stuff them in a U.S. mail priority envelope..
just e-mail me your address...)

RE: Hydrox cookies back - limited time (joanie41)

Wed, 24 Sep 2008 18:33:29 GMT

I still haven't found these in any of the stores in the Bmore area. Bummer! If you are in this area, and have found them, please let me know!

RE: Hydrox cookies back - limited time (leethebard)

Wed, 24 Sep 2008 17:59:37 GMT

What a great idea for a company...bring back a discontinued product,fpr a limited time...see if it sells to the nostalia buffs...and if it goes well enough...back in production!!!! Bring back Nabisco Cheese Tidbits...and Bonomo's Turkish Tafee!!!!!

RE: Hydrox cookies back - limited time (DavidEMartin)

Wed, 24 Sep 2008 15:48:01 GMT

The local Pick-N-Save has had Hydrox on sale 2-for$4 all month. I ate one bag myself, shared a second with friend, and still have a third sitting on the pantry shelf.
The chocolate flavor was subtler than Oreos, as befits a cookie aimed at an adult palette. The filling was smaller than an Oreo but that did not matter. It tasted better and did not have the disturbing after-feel of Oreo's white stuff.

RE: Hydrox cookies back - limited time (danimal15)

Thu, 04 Sep 2008 12:27:49 GMT

Had the Hydrox and they're a lot like Oreos. Not much difference.

The best sandwich cookies I've tried are the 365 brand available at Whole Foods. You'll never want an Oreo again.

RE: Hydrox cookies back - limited time (hutt)

Sat, 30 Aug 2008 11:22:56 GMT

I refuse to eat a Hydrox - never did, never will.
And I hate Oreos, too.
-just my two cents-

RE: Hydrox cookies back - limited time (rmcielwain)

Sat, 30 Aug 2008 10:30:38 GMT

Apparently haven't made it down south yet: checked the local Wally World last night with no success,
although they had "Newman-O's" (named for Paul Newman, not the evil mailman on "Seinfeld"). [|)]

RE: Hydrox cookies back - limited time (joanie41)

Fri, 29 Aug 2008 08:25:52 GMT

Thanks, David! I'll stop by the Safeway this weekend...we'll see if the cookies are as good as I remember...

RE: Hydrox cookies back - limited time (David_NYC)

Wed, 27 Aug 2008 23:24:09 GMT

Joanie,
Kelloggs/Keebler Cookies is behind Hydrox, and their web site has no store locator for this product. However, on page 5 of the online Circular for Safeway in Baltimore, they show as on deal for $2.50 until Sept. 2nd. Also, keep an eye out on SuperFresh, another A&P owned supermarket chain. Not on sale right now, though.

RE: Hydrox cookies back - limited time (joanie41)

Wed, 27 Aug 2008 22:12:50 GMT

I used to love Hydrox. After reading this thread, I headed out to the local supermarket here in Bmore (Shoppers Food Warehouse) and they didn't have Hydrox. Do we have a list of stores/states that are currently stocking them?

RE: Hydrox cookies back - limited time (Red Head)

Wed, 27 Aug 2008 15:37:13 GMT

I bought a couple of packs of the "Limited Edition" Hydrox this week. I think they taste pretty good but I don't think they taste the way I remember. I know they took out the trans fat and that will certainly change the texture of the filling but I seem to remember that the filling was thinner and not as soft and creamy. In my opinion and "taste memory" the texture of the filling is closer to an Oreo. has anyone done a side by side comparison to see how different they are?

RE: Hydrox cookies back - limited time (doggydaddy)

Wed, 27 Aug 2008 14:57:47 GMT

quote:
Originally posted by plb

Hydrox were around long before Oreos. Hydrox, like all treats at that time, were designed to appeal to adult’s tastes. That was because only adults had money and made all purchases.

Oreos were copied after Hydrox, but their manufacturer had what was a radical idea at the time to design a product specifically to appeal to children’s tastes. That is why Oreos are softer and sweeter while Hydrox were crisper and less sweet.

These Hydrox taste pretty good, but to me, it seems that they're lacking the complexity of the original. I think that they taste fairly close to Oreo's.

mark

RE: Hydrox cookies back - limited time (plb)

Wed, 27 Aug 2008 14:37:09 GMT

Hydrox were around long before Oreos. Hydrox, like all treats at that time, were designed to appeal to adult’s tastes. That was because only adults had money and made all purchases.

Oreos were copied after Hydrox, but their manufacturer had what was a radical idea at the time to design a product specifically to appeal to children’s tastes. That is why Oreos are softer and sweeter while Hydrox were crisper and less sweet.

RE: Hydrox cookies back - limited time (leethebard)

Wed, 27 Aug 2008 14:25:41 GMT

Wow...now we can do that side by side taste test with Oreos!!!

RE: Hydrox cookies back - limited time (PaulBPool)

Wed, 27 Aug 2008 14:13:36 GMT

Picked up a package last week, and they're already gone! Great cookie, good chocolate flavor, just the right mix of creme filling, wish they'd stay around permanently, but I guess in this day and age we should be grateful for small favors and enjoy them while we can!

RE: Hydrox cookies back - limited time (apteafan)

Wed, 27 Aug 2008 14:02:33 GMT

Great A&P is offering a special on Sunshine Hydrox cookies for the new sales week starting Labor Day weekend. The 14 oz package is just $1.89.

That got me to thinking. Wow, if Hydrox cookies can make a comeback, how about Jane Parker Cinnamon Donuts?

Any one remember just how good these little sweet donuts were???

I sure wish they make a return appearance to celebrate Great A&P's 150th annniversary celebration next year.

RE: Hydrox cookies back - limited time (drpep)

Mon, 25 Aug 2008 18:57:24 GMT

Picked up a package for $2.50. How can something be sold as 100th anniversary edition if they've only been sold from 1908-2003 and then 2008