Catskills Heimishe Bakery - Monticello, NY

Re:Catskills Heimishe Bakery - Monticello, NY (Tony White)

Thu, 11 Aug 2011 21:05:09 GMT

Catskills Heimishe Bakery Not Closed Stopped in today had a Black and white Cookie Very Good!

Re:Catskills Heimishe Bakery - Monticello, NY (Tony White)

Sun, 13 Sep 2009 21:51:34 GMT

Hi John
You must have missed my reply to your Barnstormer post in April.
Brothers is a small place with a few tables and some serious Q. I have tried the
Brisket which is excellent. My wife has had the Pulled Pork also excellent.
Now that the Summer is winding down I will have to try the Ribs. I have fun
spending the day smoking my own ribs in the warm weather. The price for
a lunch size sandwich is $5.00 which is very reasonable for the portion you
receive. They also have excellent Fresh Cut Fries.

Re:Catskills Heimishe Bakery - Monticello, NY (seafarer john)

Tue, 08 Sep 2009 12:14:58 GMT

Tony: We were on our way to Storm King Art Center a few weeks ago and saw, for the first time, the Brothers BBQ. We couldn't stop because we had the grandchildren and a picnic already packed in the car.

How long have they been there ? And, how do they compare with Barnstormer that used to be in a run-down mall in Newburgh ( now re-located in Ft Montgomery)?

Cheers, John

Re:Catskills Heimishe Bakery - Monticello, NY (Tony White)

Sun, 06 Sep 2009 00:13:36 GMT

Ellen, The Next Time You Are In The Hudson Valley You Should
Give Brothers BBQ A Try. The Best Brisket I have Had In New York And
At $5.00 A Great Value.

2402 Route 32 New Windsor, NY

845-534-4227

Re:Catskills Heimishe Bakery - Monticello, NY (ellen4641)

Sat, 05 Sep 2009 14:55:29 GMT

HI again, Tony..
I'm so glad to hear that I gave you creative inspiration to cook up a pastrami !! Way to go!!
BTW, I started a pastrami thread on Chowhound that ended up getting put in the cooking thread cause there were was lots of good tidbits on making your OWN pastrami!
Glad YOU tried it, and with good success !!

Hey, I had a real good (and huge !!) prime rib in Lochran's in Salisbury Mills in July.... a steal at $13.95
and right in your neck of the woods!

Re:Catskills Heimishe Bakery - Monticello, NY (Tony White)

Sat, 05 Sep 2009 10:50:41 GMT

Thanks Ellen I occasionally work up in Sullivan County and will check back
next summer. Your love of Pastrami led me to try making my own with surprisingly
good results. Here in Orange County there is not 1 spot that has anything like
a good Jewish Deli would serve. I do stop at Harrolds when in New Jersey when I am
in the mood for Pastrami. Rumpernooks in Fair Lawn long closed was where I had my first
Great Pastrami.

Re:Catskills Heimishe Bakery - Monticello, NY (ellen4641)

Fri, 04 Sep 2009 10:20:06 GMT

Hey, Tony, hate to see your post go unanswered, so here we go..

Most likely the bakery is just a seasonal operation...
probably closed cause it was approaching the end of the "bungalow colony" and summer camp season..
Most of the summer residents up there nowadays are the ultra Orthodox (and often Hasidic) Jewish folks coming from Brooklyn..
They stay in the bungalow colonies during the summer; often the men work their regular jobs in NYC during the week, and can only come up on weekends..

And now they are mostly all back in Brooklyn again for the winter..
and there is not enough business from the year round Monticello area folks to keep that bakery going..
(espescially with almost all the Jewish style resorts long closed)
Kutchers is still open, but I did a "walk through" in July...
and it LOOKS dead!!

Catskills Heimishe Bakery - Monticello, NY (Tony White)

Wed, 02 Sep 2009 18:33:32 GMT

Rode by Today and the Catskills Heimishe Bakery - Monticello, NY appears to be Closed.
Anyone have any info or did I miss a post about it closing