Favorite flavor

Well, a good vanilla can't be beat, but coffee flavoured is my absolute go to. If a place offers it, I'll likely get it.

I'm definitely in the pralines and cream fan club, with Mitchell's in SF being the best I've ever tasted.  Gelato--fresh ginger.  Awesome.

Mine is Peanut Butter Chip or some variation.

A few days ago I had my first taste of Jeni's at the North Market in Columbus.  It was whiskey pecan.  Very good, but actually too many pecans and not enough icecream.  I still prefer Graeter's Summer Peach.  Unfortunately it's now gone since it's no longer summer.

lleechef


A few days ago I had my first taste of Jeni's at the North Market in Columbus.  It was whiskey pecan.  Very good, but actually too many pecans and not enough icecream.  I still prefer Graeter's Summer Peach.  Unfortunately it's now gone since it's no longer summer.

That reminds me of a fun flavor called Secret Breakfast which you can get at Humphry Slocombe in SF.  It's bourbon and cornflakes in vanilla ice cream.  I mean, not real bourbon you can get drunk on, but by association, I felt like I should be getting a buzz from it. :)

I was in New England in August, where i'm from, and had the best ice cream ever.  Cotton candy at The beach Plum in Rye New Hampshire.  It was almost whipped cream texture with cotton candy mixed in.  I don't know how they do it.   I am a big fan of black raspberry, but have not found a good one in a long time.  Also, I love the seasonal flavor pumpkin.  I had it at Big Daddy's in Wells Maine. Delish.
  I live in Florida now and ice cream is not big down here like it is in the northeast, buttttt, I did have great icecream at The Waffle Cone in Flagler Beach. 

Salted caramel at Molly Moon's in Seattle.

Chocolate and peanut butter (the kind that has swirls of PB, not Reese's cups or anything).

My favorite of all time is probably the individually wrapped spumoni slices you sometimes get served at Italian weddings ... that and Italian Lemon Ices (I know, not exactly an ice cream).
 
When I was a kid and going out for ice cream to Baskin & Robbins I'd usually order a double dip ... Daiquiri Ice and Lime Sherbet. 
 
I liked Blue Moon and Superman as well.
 
Recently, I had an awesome sundae made with vanilla ice cream, Coca-Cola syrup and salted peanuts on top.  It was a bit like putting salted peanuts in your bottle of Coke when you drink it.

I recently had Graeter's black cherry, and it's a winner for me. Of course I'm waiting for the wonderful peach ice cream come summer.

All from Graeter's:
Orange and Cream (tastes like an old-fashioned creamsicle!)
Blueberry Pie
Black Cherry

was in rhode island and massachusetts last week and stopped at grays in rhode island and had the frozen pudding ice cream was very good as always wish i could get it here in buffalo.

At the minute I have an appreciation for this whiskey ice cream http://www.nigoodfood.com/Glastry%202.pdf