The most memorable local eateries along the highways and back roads of America
Sign In | Register for Free!
Restaurants Recipes Forums EatingTours Merchandise FAQ Maps Insider
Forum Themes:
Welcome !

 Weekend in Indy

Change Page: < 12345 | Showing page 5 of 5, messages 121 to 128 of 128
Author Message
deeoh01

  • Total Posts: 62
  • Joined: 4/9/2008
  • Location: Indy, IN
RE: Weekend in Indy Tue, 09/29/09 3:16 PM (permalink)
The Travelin Man


I really thought that I was the only one completely underwhelmed by St. Elmo Steakhouse.  When I was in Indianapolis last fall, I was really looking forward to my visit there, and was pretty disappointed.  Since I really wanted a good steak, I dug myself a further hole by attempting the upscale Shula's Steakhouse inside my hotel.  Yeah, I know it's a chain - but, it met two of my rules - I had not been to one, and there is not one where I live.  Needless to say, I won't have to worry about going back a second time. 

Poor, poor steak-deprived Indianapolis.



There are plenty of places to get a great steak, but St. Elmo just isn't one of them.  Neither is Shula's.  Chains that are better than either one:  Ruth's Chris, Morton's, Capital Grille, Sullivan's, Flemings, Fogo de Chao.  Local places I'd go to before St. Elmo would be Mo's, Peterson's, Dunaway's or Broad Ripple Steakhouse.
 
    rhomp2002

    • Total Posts: 4
    • Joined: 5/7/2007
    • Location: jamaica, NY
    RE: Weekend in Indy Tue, 09/29/09 3:41 PM (permalink)
    Speaking of upscale restaurants in Indianapolis, many years ago, probably about 1978 or so, my boss, his wife and I drove to a convention in Kansas City.  On the way we stopped in Indianapolis overnight and ate in a restaurant called Hugo's that was in the hotel where we stayed.  My buddy still claims that was the best meal he ever had in any restaurant.  He can still tell you every item he ate.  Have not been back to Indianapolis since so I don't know if it even exists any more but it was outstanding indeed.  Loved the town as well. 

    I grew up in a small place in central Ohio not too far from Columbus and finished a contract in Cincinnati about 10 years ago before I retired and love that section of the country, especially Cincinnati.  Would move back there in a heartbeat from here in NYC.

    My dad's family is from the corner of Ohio where Pennsylvania and West Virginia and Ohio all come together and I have family in all 3 states.  Love that area as well.  Just something about the people and how friendly and helpful they are.  Sure don't get that much here in the city.
     
      wanderingjew

      • Total Posts: 7379
      • Joined: 1/18/2001
      • Location: East Greenwich/ Warwick, RI
      • Roadfood Insider
      RE: Weekend in Indy Wed, 09/30/09 7:29 PM (permalink)
      Ok,

      You know me, I simply don't "get" the BBQ  and Deli thing  (in Indianapolis??)

      However with those photos of the Fried Chicken at Hollyhock Hill, I really regret being too full to really enjoy my meal when I visited last year.
       
        claracamille

        • Total Posts: 414
        • Joined: 1/31/2004
        • Location: Idpls, IN
        RE: Weekend in Indy Sun, 10/4/09 1:55 PM (permalink)
        I agree about St. Elmo's, the shrimp cocktail is to die for but the steaks are just so-so, definitely not worth the money.  Our 2 favorite & most consistant upscale steak restaurants in Indy are Peterson's & Sullivan's, both on the north side. 
        Our other favorite steak place is Murphy's Steakhouse.  The steaks are not prime, but they hancut their steaks & I love the ribeye.  Their signature salad has a great hot bacon dressing & the side are consistantly tasty.   Great desserts at $5 each.  Most of the waitstaff has been there for years & you may be called "honey" or "sweetie".  Also, every week there are coupons in the local paper.
         
        We both have a great steak meal at Murphy's with dessert & pay  less than 1 meal at one of the upscale places.
         
          buffetbuster

          RE: Weekend in Indy Mon, 10/5/09 8:38 AM (permalink)
          wanderingjew


          Ok,

          You know me, I simply don't "get" the BBQ  and Deli thing  (in Indianapolis??)
          Prepare to be disappointed in me again, because I will be back in Indy a month from now and I already know Shapiro's is on the agenda.

           
            Train

            • Total Posts: 23
            • Joined: 4/19/2001
            • Location: Indianapolis,
            RE: Weekend in Indy Sun, 10/25/09 7:18 PM (permalink)
            Buffetbuster,
            Next time you're in Indy, you might try Judge's Barbecue on the near-westside, whose ribs I find quite a bit better than King Ribs. Good sides too, especially the corn casserole. The trouble is they have really inconvenient hours: The only day they're open evenings is Friday, when they close at 8pm. Otherwise, they close at 4:00 and aren't open at all on the weekend. Anyway, if it happens to fit your schedule, they're at 2104 W Michigan Street. The phone is (317)631-0340. 
             
              buffetbuster

              RE: Weekend in Indy Mon, 10/26/09 5:48 PM (permalink)
              Train

              Next time you're in Indy, you might try Judge's Barbecue on the near-westside, whose ribs I find quite a bit better than King Ribs. 
              Quite a bit better?  Than King Ribs?  Wow!  This I gotta try!  Thanks for the tip.

               
                joerogo

                • Total Posts: 4462
                • Joined: 1/17/2006
                • Location: Pittston, PA
                RE: Weekend in Indy Mon, 10/26/09 7:18 PM (permalink)
                Train


                Buffetbuster,
                Next time you're in Indy, you might try Judge's Barbecue on the near-westside, whose ribs I find quite a bit better than King Ribs. Good sides too, especially the corn casserole. The trouble is they have really inconvenient hours: The only day they're open evenings is Friday, when they close at 8pm. Otherwise, they close at 4:00 and aren't open at all on the weekend. Anyway, if it happens to fit your schedule, they're at 2104 W Michigan Street. The phone is (317)631-0340. 


                Anyplace with hours like that has GOT to be good!
                 
                  Online Bookmarks Sharing: Share/Bookmark
                  Change Page: < 12345 | Showing page 5 of 5, messages 121 to 128 of 128

                  Jump to:

                  Current active users

                  There are 0 members and 2 guests.

                  Icon Legend and Permission

                  • New Messages
                  • No New Messages
                  • Hot Topic w/ New Messages
                  • Hot Topic w/o New Messages
                  • Locked w/ New Messages
                  • Locked w/o New Messages
                  • Read Message
                  • Post New Thread
                  • Reply to message
                  • Post New Poll
                  • Submit Vote
                  • Post reward post
                  • Delete my own posts
                  • Delete my own threads
                  • Rate post

                  2000-2014 ASPPlayground.NET Forum Version 3.9
                  What is Roadfood?  |   Privacy Policy  |   Contact Roadfood.com   Copyright 2011 - Roadfood.com