Your Guide to Authentic Regional Eats
Sign In | Register for Free!
Restaurants Recipes Forums Eating Tours Merchandise FAQ Maps Insider

Jack Pandl's Whitefish Bay Inn

1319 East Henry Clay St., Milwaukee, WI - (414) 964-3800
Posted By Michael Stern on 4/20/2015 5:33:00 AM
The drive from Milwaukee along the shore of Lake Michigan to Jack Pandl’s is worth the trip just to view the scenery. The lake is beautiful and mansions at water’s edge are an extravagant array of sturdy Midwestern design and old-money style.

Pandl’s is a cozy Bavarian lodge house decorated with beer steins, staffed by waitresses in dirndl skirts. The menu is pricey by our usual standards, and your fellow diners will include a large portion of bluehairs who have been coming here for lunch seemingly since the restaurant’s opening in 1915. It isn’t a fancy place – bare tables are set with paper placemats – but it has an old-world gentility that makes meals seem at least semi-formal.

The kitchen’s repertoire includes all manner of steak, seafood, and salad; but we come for a few distinct menu items that are heart-and-soul Wisconsin. A frequent daily special is liver-dumpling soup, a homey broth filled vegetables and with one dark, tender dumpling. You can always get a plate of walleyed pike or, better yet, broiled whitefish; the latter is a pretty fillet that is toasty-sweet, cream-tender, and satisfying in a way that only lake fish ever is. The one necessary thing to eat at Pandl’s is the German pancake – a baked ‘cake similar to Yorkshire pudding that rises up in the oven to form a huge, eggy trough into which you sprinkle powdered sugar and a squeeze of lemon to form a tart-sweet syrup.

For dessert, Pandl’s offers schaum torte, an appealing bowl of sweetness in shades of white, pink, and red. Pure, crunchy meringue is topped with ivory smooth custard and a spill of strawberries in syrup. The harmony of textures and varying degrees of sweetness make schaum torte a pleasure from first bite to last.

13 out of 13 people found the review helpful. Was it helpful to you?

No Yes

Scorecard

5 - Overall: Legendary - Worth driving from anyplace
Overall: Legendary - Worth driving from anyplace
German Pancake
schaum torte
broiled whitefish
Wiener Schnitzel
Fried Lake Perch
Rate this place

Reviewers Photos [Upload Your Photos]

A close-up of the broiled whitefish reveals its flaky, tender character.
"A close-up of the broiled whitefish reveals its flaky, tender character."
Cliff Strutz





Unfortunately, the liver dumpling soup isn't always available.  This cup of comforting chicken dumpling soup makes a fine substitute.
"Unfortunately, the liver dumpling soup isn't always available. This cup of comforting chicken dumpling soup makes a fine substitute."
Cliff Strutz


Brittle-crisp with a ribbon of tender meat inside, these wavy wiener schnitzel patties are divine.
"Brittle-crisp with a ribbon of tender meat inside, these wavy wiener schnitzel patties are divine."
Michael Stern


On the left: potato pancakes. Right: three perch double-filets, i.e. each of the three was both sides of a whole perch, boned of course. The breading is light gold and toasty; the meat inside is freshwater sweet.
"On the left: potato pancakes. Right: three perch double-filets, i.e. each of the three was both sides of a whole perch, boned of course. The breading is light gold and toasty; the meat inside is freshwater sweet."
Michael Stern


Outstanding cole slaw! It is crisp, pickly, and refreshing, dotted with bits of tomato, red and green pepper, and onion
"Outstanding cole slaw! It is crisp, pickly, and refreshing, dotted with bits of tomato, red and green pepper, and onion"
Michael Stern


If you visit Jack Pandl's on a Sunday, your brunch starts off with this plate of pastries.
"If you visit Jack Pandl's on a Sunday, your brunch starts off with this plate of pastries."
Cliff Strutz


Make your own syrup for the German pancake by squeezing on fresh lemon juice and combining that with a measure of powdered sugar.
"Make your own syrup for the German pancake by squeezing on fresh lemon juice and combining that with a measure of powdered sugar."
Michael Stern


A cup of Jack Pandl's liver-dumpling soup
"A cup of Jack Pandl's liver-dumpling soup"
Michael Stern


A beautiful sight for the eyes, this dessert consisting of custard, meringue and strawberries is as delicious as it looks!
"A beautiful sight for the eyes, this dessert consisting of custard, meringue and strawberries is as delicious as it looks!"
Cliff Strutz


One small fraction of Pandl's collection of beer steins.
"One small fraction of Pandl's collection of beer steins."
Michael Stern


One of Milwaukee's longstanding culinary treasures.
"One of Milwaukee's longstanding culinary treasures."
Michael Stern



What is Roadfood?  |   Submit Content  |   Privacy Policy  |   Contact Roadfood.com   Copyright - Roadfood.com