Your Guide to Authentic Regional Eats
Sign In | Register for Free!
Restaurants Recipes Forums Eating Tours Merchandise FAQ Maps Insider

Primanti Brothers

46 18th St., Pittsburgh, PA - (412) 263-2142
Posted By Michael Stern on 11/24/2014 8:35:00 AM
There are Primanti Brothers all over the place in Pittsburgh and as far away now as Florida, but the original, in the Strip District, remains a worthy destination. It is open ‘round the clock, attracting a wide-ranging clientele of truckers, shippers, sports fans, and club-denizens with no place else to go when the bars close in the wee hours. Don’t come if you are looking for peace and quiet, for this is a hugely boisterous joint, throbbing through dawn with people drinking Iron City beer and chowing down on some of the most amazing sandwiches ever constructed.

Primanti Brothers’ Dagwoods were originally designed for truckers who hauled produce to the nearby wholesale market. While their trucks were being unloaded, they dashed in to the restaurant with a big appetite but little time to fuss over a sandwich, an order of cole slaw, and fried potatoes all nicely and separately arranged on a plate. The solution was to load hot French fries directly into the sandwich atop the customer’s meat of choice, then top the fries with Pittsburgh-style (no mayo) cole slaw and a few slices of tomato: an all-in-one meal between two pieces of bread. The sandwiches are assembled at the grill behind the bar at the speed of light, so when the sandwich is delivered, the fries and grilled meats are still steaming hot, the slaw and tomato cool. It is common to see customers who are, shall we say, a wee bit tipsy (at 4am) sink their teeth deep into one of these big babies and pull away with the shock of the meat’s heat on their tongue.

Bizarre as the pile-up of courses sounds, Primanti Brothers fans insist that such favored combinations as double-egg and pastrami (both sizzled on the grill) or steak and cheese simply do not taste right if not capped with a layer of crisp-fried potatoes and another of slaw. The double-fistful meal is presented at the counter and at tables wrapped in butcher paper that serves as a plate and also as a drop-cloth to pick up the spillage.

23 out of 23 people found the review helpful. Was it helpful to you?

No Yes

Scorecard

4 - Overall: One of the Best - Worth a Trip
Overall: One of the Best - Worth a Trip
double egg and pastrami sandwich
corn beef and egg
cheese steak sandwich
Baloney, Egg, and Cheese Sandwich
Rate this place

Reviewers Photos [Upload Your Photos]

An inside view of a kolbassi sandwich shows the distinct layers of ingredients.  Everything works in harmony, but it's the crisp vinegar slaw that shines for me,
"An inside view of a kolbassi sandwich shows the distinct layers of ingredients. Everything works in harmony, but it's the crisp vinegar slaw that shines for me,"
Cliff Strutz





The capicola with cheese is my go-to sandwich at Primanti's.  The spiciness of the ham, combined with the creaminess of the fries' interior and coleslaw's vinegary tang, make for an unbeatable combination.
"The capicola with cheese is my go-to sandwich at Primanti's. The spiciness of the ham, combined with the creaminess of the fries' interior and coleslaw's vinegary tang, make for an unbeatable combination."
Cliff Strutz


Roast beef, Pittsburgh-style slaw, sliced tomatoes, fresh french fries, egg, and simply tasty bread.
"Roast beef, Pittsburgh-style slaw, sliced tomatoes, fresh french fries, egg, and simply tasty bread."
Adam Cohen


The very busy Primanti's grill.
"The very busy Primanti's grill."
Cliff Strutz


On a short counter adjacent to the grill, sandwiches are assembled faster than the eye can see.
"On a short counter adjacent to the grill, sandwiches are assembled faster than the eye can see."
Michael Stern


Corned beef with egg. This is the only place that I eat fried eggs.One of my favorite sandwiches in the US.
"Corned beef with egg. This is the only place that I eat fried eggs.One of my favorite sandwiches in the US."
bill eaton


The doors never close at Primanti Brothers in the Pittsburgh Strip.  Walk in any time, and you are guaranteed a counter crowded with colorful sandwich devotees.
"The doors never close at Primanti Brothers in the Pittsburgh Strip. Walk in any time, and you are guaranteed a counter crowded with colorful sandwich devotees."
Michael Stern


Among the Pittsburghers immortalized on the lengthy wall mural is Henry Mancini, Andrew Carnegie, and Bruno Sammartino.
"Among the Pittsburghers immortalized on the lengthy wall mural is Henry Mancini, Andrew Carnegie, and Bruno Sammartino."
Cliff Strutz


Forget 'less is more.' At Primanti's, More is More.
"Forget 'less is more.' At Primanti's, More is More."
Michael Stern



What is Roadfood?  |   Submit Content  |   Privacy Policy  |   Contact Roadfood.com   Copyright - Roadfood.com