Over the past quarter century, Herrell's has tripled in size from a single store in Northhampton to include shops in Allston and Cambridge as well. This is the birthplace of the ice cream smoosh-in, where Reese's Peanut Butter Cups, fruits, nuts or other mix-ins found their way into creamy base flavors long before the emergence of Cold Stones and Marble Slabs. This type of innovation remains today, as Herrell's rotates through nearly 200 different flavors. Whereas some of these flavors were first concocted over 30 years ago (like Malted Vanilla and Chocolate Pudding), new and different flavors emerge all the time (such as a frosty Root Beer)!
| Overall Experience |  |
| Chocolate Pudding Ice Cream -
This flavor will take you back to your childhood. Just like a creamy Fudgesicle, except with a bolder and more mature taste. |
|
| Mud Pie Ice Cream -
Espresso ice cream with Hydrox cookies and hot fudge, the balance between the coffee flavor and crunchy cookies was spot on. |
|
| Malted Vanilla Ice Cream -
Creamy, smooth, and just like a melted vanilla malt! |
 |
| Vanilla Ice Cream -
Speckled with vanilla beans, this vanilla flavor was bold. |
|
| Hot Fudge Sauce -
Not too bitter, but very flavorful. A homemade sauce worthy of standing on its own. |
|
Quick Links:
More of The Best New England Ice Cream:
-
Annabelle's Ice Cream - Portsmouth, NH
-
Ashley's Ice Cream - New Haven, CT
-
Beals Ice Cream - Portland, ME
-
Bedford Farms - Bedford, MA
-
Ben & Bill's Chocolate Emporium - Falmouth, MA
-
Benson's Ice Cream - West Boxford, MA
-
Big Dipper Ice Cream Factory - Prospect, CT
-
Bishop's Ice Cream - Littleton, NH
-
Brickley's Ice Cream & Cakes - Narragansett, RI
-
Brown's Ice Cream - York, ME
-
Bubbling Brook Restaurant - Westwood, MA
-
Buttonwood Farms - Griswold, CT
-
Chelsea Royal Diner - West Brattleboro, VT
-
Christina's Homemade Ice Cream - Cambridge, MA
-
Cows and Cones - Gales Ferry, CT
-
Crescent Ridge Dairy Bar - Sharon, MA
-
Daily Scoop - Kennebunk, ME
-
Dorman's Dairy Dream - Thomaston, ME
-
Dr. Mike's - Bethel, CT
-
Emack & Bolio's - Orleans, MA
-
Four Seas Ice Cream - Centerville, MA
-
Gray's Ice Cream - Tiverton, RI
-
Herrell's Ice Cream - Allston, MA
-
Hodgie's Ice Cream - Amesbury, MA
-
Ice Cream Machine - Cumberland, RI
-
J.P. Licks - Brookline, MA
-
Kimball Farm Ice Cream - Carlisle, MA
-
Lago's Lone Oak - Rochester, NH
-
Lizzy's Ice Cream - Waltham, MA
-
Michael's Dairy - New London, CT
-
Old Lyme Ice Cream Shop - Old Lyme, CT
-
Peaceful Meadows Farm - Whitman, MA
-
Rancatore's Ice Cream - Belmont, MA
-
Rich Farm - Oxford, CT
-
Richardson's Ice Cream - Middleton, MA
-
Round Top Ice Cream - Damariscotta, ME
-
Shady Glen - Manchester, CT
-
Shain's of Maine - Sanford, ME
-
Shaw Farm - Dracut, MA
-
Shaw's Ridge Farm - Sanford, ME
-
Smiling Hill Farm - Westbrook, ME
-
Soco Creamery - Great Barrington, MA
-
Sullivan Farms - Tyngsboro, MA
-
Sundae School - Dennisport, MA
-
The Collins Creamery - Enfield, CT
-
The Daily Scoop - Bristol, RI
-
The James Gallery & Soda Fountain - Old Saybrook, CT
-
The Juice Bar - Nantucket, MA
-
Timothy's - Bridgeport, CT
-
Toots Ice Cream - North Yarmouth, ME
-
Toscanini's - Cambridge, MA
-
Tubby's Ice Cream - Wayne, ME
-
UConn Dairy Bar - Storrs, CT
-
White Farms Ice Cream - Ipswich, MA
