Although there are now three locations on the Cape, 2008 marks the 30th anniversary of the Dennisport store. Step up to the marble soda fountain counter to order a frappe, ice cream soda, or sundae served in an old-fashioned glass dish. The ambience inside the historic barn serves to enhance the ice cream experience, from the antique signs on the walls to the pennants (of colleges attended by current and former scoopers) carpeting the rafters. Although the ice cream is made daily in small batches, this luckily does not translate into a lack of flavor choices. Both ice cream purists and mix-in junkies will each be pleased by the quality of the flavors as well as the presence of candies, nuts, or fruits in every spoonful.
| Overall Experience |  |
| Bass River Mud Ice Cream -
This mud pie-type flavor has certainly been done before, but few versions can rival the success achieved at Sundae School. The combination of a solid coffee flavor and abundant mix-ins made for a perfect pick. |
 |
| Pirate Pandemonium Ice Cream -
A flavor sensation! The peanut butter ice cream would have been a solid stand-alone, but the crunch and salt of the pretzels truly enhanced the scoop. |
 |
| Vanilla Ice Cream -
Fantastic flavor and incredibly smooth texture. |
 |
| Hot Fudge Sauce -
Incredibly thick and cleaved like butter. |
 |
Quick Links:
More of The Best New England Ice Cream:
-
Annabelle's Ice Cream - Portsmouth, NH
-
Ashley's Ice Cream - New Haven, CT
-
Beals Ice Cream - Portland, ME
-
Bedford Farms - Bedford, MA
-
Ben & Bill's Chocolate Emporium - Falmouth, MA
-
Benson's Ice Cream - West Boxford, MA
-
Big Dipper Ice Cream Factory - Prospect, CT
-
Bishop's Ice Cream - Littleton, NH
-
Brickley's Ice Cream & Cakes - Narragansett, RI
-
Brown's Ice Cream - York, ME
-
Bubbling Brook Restaurant - Westwood, MA
-
Buttonwood Farms - Griswold, CT
-
Chelsea Royal Diner - West Brattleboro, VT
-
Christina's Homemade Ice Cream - Cambridge, MA
-
Cows and Cones - Gales Ferry, CT
-
Crescent Ridge Dairy Bar - Sharon, MA
-
Daily Scoop - Kennebunk, ME
-
Dorman's Dairy Dream - Thomaston, ME
-
Dr. Mike's - Bethel, CT
-
Emack & Bolio's - Orleans, MA
-
Four Seas Ice Cream - Centerville, MA
-
Gray's Ice Cream - Tiverton, RI
-
Herrell's Ice Cream - Allston, MA
-
Hodgie's Ice Cream - Amesbury, MA
-
Ice Cream Machine - Cumberland, RI
-
J.P. Licks - Brookline, MA
-
Kimball Farm Ice Cream - Carlisle, MA
-
Lago's Lone Oak - Rochester, NH
-
Lizzy's Ice Cream - Waltham, MA
-
Michael's Dairy - New London, CT
-
Old Lyme Ice Cream Shop - Old Lyme, CT
-
Peaceful Meadows Farm - Whitman, MA
-
Rancatore's Ice Cream - Belmont, MA
-
Rich Farm - Oxford, CT
-
Richardson's Ice Cream - Middleton, MA
-
Round Top Ice Cream - Damariscotta, ME
-
Shady Glen - Manchester, CT
-
Shain's of Maine - Sanford, ME
-
Shaw Farm - Dracut, MA
-
Shaw's Ridge Farm - Sanford, ME
-
Smiling Hill Farm - Westbrook, ME
-
Soco Creamery - Great Barrington, MA
-
Sullivan Farms - Tyngsboro, MA
-
Sundae School - Dennisport, MA
-
The Collins Creamery - Enfield, CT
-
The Daily Scoop - Bristol, RI
-
The James Gallery & Soda Fountain - Old Saybrook, CT
-
The Juice Bar - Nantucket, MA
-
Timothy's - Bridgeport, CT
-
Toots Ice Cream - North Yarmouth, ME
-
Toscanini's - Cambridge, MA
-
Tubby's Ice Cream - Wayne, ME
-
UConn Dairy Bar - Storrs, CT
-
White Farms Ice Cream - Ipswich, MA